Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
29 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Dark and beautifully crafted, 23 Jan 2004
This is a dark and skilfully-woven book that held me in thrall and then ended so abruptly that it felt as if the power had been cut. Hawksmoor was ahead of its time, playfully flaunting literary devices that are almost cinematic and have since become widely used. For instance, the narrative flashes backwards and forwards in time, and strange resonances accumulate until past and future become entwined. Words and phrases leap across centuries, and characters overlap in life and death in a chilling and macabre dance.
Much of the narrative is delivered in first person by Nick Dyer, acolyte of Sir Christopher Wren and practitioner of satanic arts. Ackroyd serves up with relish the foul deeds and alarming inner thoughts of Dyer, whose churches rise up as temples of darkness alongside contemporary works that are designed to celebrate enlightenment, science and engineering.
Ackroyd so immersed himself in 17th-century English (he claims to have read over 200 books from that time while researching, or perhaps rehearsing, Hawksmoor) that Dyer's first-person narrative is credible, readable and well-paced.
If you are new to Ackroyd, start here. If not, be prepared to find a black and elliptical side to him that might surprise you.
|
|
|
16 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Better than LONDON, 20 Mar 2001
By A Customer
I read this after LONDON, A BIOGRAPHY and I must say right away that it is by far and away a better book at every possible level -- better written, better imagined and better balanced! I have read Moorcock's MOTHER LONDON and Sinclair's DOWN RIVER and while this doesn't have their scope, it has some of their depth. Ackroyd's work sometimes seems a bit schematic, with an echo of the academic about it and his novels often don't ever seem to get beyond a bit of theory, but I would recommend this novel to everyone. While it's well-known that Lud Heat by Sinclair was the inspiration of Hawksmoor, Ackroyd's common touch make his book far more accessible than Sinclair's. It would make a superb movie and I'm really surprised some film director hasn't jumped on it with cries of joy. It wouldn't cost that much to make, either! JB
|
|
|
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
I wandr'd the Dark Streets of London..., 7 Aug 2007
This book was given to me not long after it was published nearly twenty years ago. This does not mean that I am a slow reader, merely that I am easily distracted by other pieces of fiction that come my way. It would be extremely harsh of me to say that my intuition to leave Peter Ackroyd's Hawksmoor was justified but literary stylistics over a plot that should have absorbed me left me feeling cheated at the novels conclusion.
For all the literary accolades that this book was afforded, in hindsight they seem misplaced. Yes, it is a credit to the skill of Peter Ackroyd that he can maintain a dual narrative in which the same actions are replayed over a two hundred year period (1700's/1980's) and he can use the vernacular, idioms and syntax of the two separate centuries over alternating chapters, but this does not make him a 'virtuoso writer'.
In the classic canon of gothic literature (Poe, Shelly, Hogg, Stevenson...) and modern (King, Herbert, Barker...) one consistent feature of terrorising your audience is the authors taut psychological control over the information which is administered gradually. What prevents Hawksmoor from being a great read as opposed to the `I-cannot-get-sleep-until-I finish-the-last-chapter' tension elicited by Stephen Kings' better horrors is the structural weakness of alternating actions between centuries. By the time we come round to the actions of Sir Nicolas Hawksmoor or Detective Hawksmoor, my interest has waned; that, in a gothic genre, is fatal.
The other cardinal rule of the gothic is that we are fascinated by the central character. Here, we do have character that is truly intriguing , morally repugnant and spiritually suspect in the form of Sir Nic. whose architecture is incredibly sinister (even in daylight.) However, human sacrifices aside, he does not have the power to really chill you. Detective Hawksmoor (the other central protagonist) is simply two-dimensional.
Hawksmoor on the whole is a missed opportunity because the central metaphysical premise to the novel is very powerful and could have evoked more potently the deep-rooted human anxieties of predestination. Hawksmoor, like present day London, can , in turns thrill with the dark history of its past whilst you meander in the pedestrian banality of its present.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Peter Ackroyd
by Peter Ackroyd
by Kerry Downes
by Peter Ackroyd
by Peter Ackroyd
