Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
24 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
No fur bik' inis!, 6 Oct 2004
By A Customer
None of the reviews of this book so far do it justice. If you've given up on fantasy because it's all the same, and it's full of women in fur bikinis or red-haired heroines with violet eyes, or kitchen boys who happen to have misplaced their kingdoms or - even worse - characters with random apostrophes in their names (Robert Jordan please step forward) - then you must give this book a try before you desert the shores of fantasy for ever. 'Paladin of Souls' is an emotionally resonant, gripping, and yet gently domestic fantasy. Ista, the protagonist, is not a typical heroine. She is a mature woman who believes her life is behind her, her family think she is mad and she knows she has committed a desperate and dammning sin for which she has yet to forgive herself. It's easier for reviewers to get to grips with Cazaril's tale in the previous book 'Curse of Chalion; his sacrifices and drives are more easily understood in terms of standard fantasy heroics, though none the less exciting and absorbing. I think Ista would be amused at how little understanding of her narrative the previous reviews show. In the everyday piety of the realm of Chalion, Ista's rage and despair against her gods and against the restrictions of her life mark her out for a spectacular, deeply moving experience of being pushed, tugged and cajoled toward a new destiny, but it is made clear to her that she can choose for herself, to reject or to accept. Her encounter with a - literally - godforsaken individual closely connected with the most dark deed of Ista's life, is the catalyst for Ista to choose. Don't be put off - one need nor be religious in any way to be gripped by the emotional undertow of the fight against depression and despair vying all the time with the mordant humour and spritely intelligence of Bujold's heroine. The nature of Bujold's world- building for Chalion has a particular form based on the beliefs of the inhabitants and the existence of absolute beings. It's not in any way offensive or intrusive. I urge you to read this novel - it's really one of the best fantasy novels I've read in ages.
|
|
|
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Paladin of Souls, 8 Jun 2004
By A Customer
McMaster Bujold is a master of science fiction; in this sequel to the Curse of Chalion she shows that she is also a master of fantasy. Instead of spectacular sorcerous powers attributed to the main characters, an intricate system of five gods is behind the magic in this world. In this book, middle-aged, cynical, mad (?) dowager royina Ista makes a journey of growth and self-discovery comparable to any coming-of-age theme in other books - and oh, so much more interesting! Although not a feminist utopia, there is more room for female heroism in this world, and a more gender embracing and un-hypocritical religion than most. The book develops more evenly than its predecessor, with as prominent characters, and some surprising turns. It also features a happy ending, and an emerging love story, which may be offensive to some readers. A general theme in Bujold's books is the physically weak hero/heroine - but none of them is painfully pathetic, like Covenant the unbeliever, or similar characters. More in the inspiring vein - we can be heroes, too! Perhaps this is Harry Potter for adults, with political intrigue instead of boarding school injustice? (And we will still read Harry Potter ...)
|
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Bujold continues a winning formula, 1 Dec 2004
This is just a fabulous book. Read it, even if you don't like fantasy. The characters are well-drawn and utterly believable, and the religious and cultural system is consistent. It helps to have read the first book, Curse of Chalion, which gives more of a background, but it's not necessary (though it, too, is a great read). All in all, thoroughly recommended.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|