Amazon.co.uk Review
"I have decided to try again", Karen Armstrong writes at the beginning of
The Spiral Staircase, in explaining why she is telling her life story for a second time, 20 years after doing so in
Beginning the World. "We should probably all pause to confront our past from time to time, because it changes its meaning as our circumstances alter." That's a clue to the sort of open-minded and intensive inquiry that Armstrong is capable of, which has made her, in those 20 years, a bestselling theologian and historian of religion, known for such hugely popular books as
The Battle for God,
A History of God, and
Islam: A Short History.
In the lucid yet reflective manner that is Armstrong's trademark, The Spiral Staircase recalls her painful early life as a nun, her even more painful reentry into secular society, and most compellingly, the long-undiagnosed epilepsy that made her life a horror show of phantom visions and misplaced hours. We follow Armstrong to the Middle East and elsewhere as she searches for answers to questions no less daunting than the significance of faith. Yet what drives Armstrong is her distaste for and distrust of those who see only black or white, never shades of grey. "I disliked the crusading certainty of Ayatollah Khomeini, yet I was also disturbed by the shrill rhetoric of some of Rushdie's champions", she writes in the wake of debate over Salman Rushdie's Satanic Verses and the ensuing fatwa issued by the extremists on the Islamic right. Indeed, as religious dogma divides the world in ever new ways, Armstrong's learned views are especially resonant. But The Spiral Staircase, its name inspired by TS Eliot's poem cycle Ash-Wednesday, is not a polemic, despite Armstrong's forceful and persuasive arguments for religious tolerance. Rather, it's a beautiful letter sent by a gifted writer attempting to decode the meaning of her life. --Kim Hughes, Amazon.com
Review
Praise for The Battle for God: 'The quality of this remarkable book lies as much in its detail as in its sweeping vision' Daily Telegraph'Armstrong displays all her usual talents: she has an eye for colourful evidence, a wonderful gift for clarity of exposition and an unerring sense of pace and voice and narrative.' Felipe Fernandez-Armesto, Literary ReviewPraise for The History for God: 'Only those who think they know it all will fail to be fascinated by Armstrong's search for God.' The Economist'Highly readable and ought to be read...Karen Armstong has read widely, has missed nothing, and gives us as solid a purview of the God of the past as it would be possible to find in a book,' Anthony Burgess, Observer'Karen Armstrong is a genius.' A. N. Wilson
This is Karen Armstrong's second sequel to Through the Narrow Gate in which she related her experiences as a Roman Catholic nun. Dissatisfied with her first attempt to describe the years following her departure from the convent she has now written a lucid and moving account of how difficult it has been to achieve peace and confidence in herself. Using the imagery of Eliot's poem Ash Wednesday she tells of her constant struggle to rise above disappointment and defeat. Careers in Scholarship and teaching showed her that she was clever but so damaged by the training she had undergone in her order that she had become unable to feel and think for herself. To make matters worse, her fainting fits and memory loss were misdiagnosed and it was not until a doctor told her that she was suffering from epilepsy that she finally achieved tranquillity and success as a writer. Very moving. (Kirkus UK)
An introspective, decidedly un-cheery work that seeks to set the author's record straight. After Armstrong wrote an account of her seven years as a Catholic nun (Through the Narrow Gate, 1981), she followed it up with a cheery but admittedly untruthful memoir depicting her new life outside the convent (Beginning the World, 1983). Now, to describe the turnings her life took as she struggled to find her way in a secular world, Armstrong (Islam, 2000, etc.) adopts the image of a spiral staircase as a symbol of spiritual progress in T.S. Eliot's Ash-Wednesday. First as a student at Oxford, where she earned a B.A. and M. Litt., but failed to obtain a doctorate, and then as a teacher in a private girls' school in London, a position from which she was dismissed after a few years, she was what can best be described as an emotional wreck. Fainting spells while still in the convent progressed to episodes of amnesia and panic attacks, which led to years of useless sessions with psychiatrists, anorexia, even a suicide attempt and hospitalizations. Finally, in 1976, a physician recognized her epileptic seizures for what they were and put her on appropriate medication. At a loss as to how to make a living after losing her teaching job, Armstrong was in despair when publicity surrounding her first book brought her TV work. An early disastrous appearance convinced her that she could not make a career out of being an ex-nun, and when a chance to write a low-budget documentary on the early Christians came along, she grabbed it. By 1983 she was in Israel researching her subject. Exposure to Judaism and Islam while in the Middle East set her on a new course: writing about the historical development of the three great Abrahamic faiths, and in doing so examining her own ideas about religion, spirituality, and God. From her teenage search for God in a convent and her subsequent attempts to debunk religion, Armstrong struggled to clarify her own beliefs. What matters, she concludes at last, is not dogma, or right belief, but right action-in a nutshell, the Golden Rule. Well-written and relentlessly self-aware. (Kirkus Reviews)