|
|
47 of 64 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
A Disappointment, 2 Dec 2003
I wish I could be kinder to this book, because I am so impressed with the excellent yearly "Halliwell's Film and Video Guide," but I find "Halliwell's Who's Who in the Movies" to be a serious disappointment. True, there are more than 12,000 bios, but practically all of the biographical entries are taken up by a list of films with little other information. For a director as important as François Truffaut the entire article consists solely of (1) the dates of birth and death; (2) the statement: "French 'new wave' director, former critic. Died of a brain tumour."; (3) the titles of his supposed autobiography and his book on Hitchcock; (4) the film list (UK titles only); and (5) two short quotes by Truffaut. I write "supposed autobiography” because the cited work is, in fact, not an autobiography at all but a collection of Truffaut's early film criticism. For some film makers the biography in "Halliwell's" may be limited to two words, such as "American director." Eric Rohmer's bio is limited to a single dismissive and mildly insulting remark: "French director of rarefied conversation pieces." Robert Bresson fares little better. At the same time, UK directors like Ken Loach or Lindsay Anderson, worthy men indeed but whose importance is certainly far less than Truffaut's, receive generous bios and a great many quotes. This inaccurate and stingy bio of Truffaut in "Halliwell's Who's Who" should be compared with the detailed bio in Ephraim Katz' "The Film Encyclopedia," where approximately 1000 words are devoted to his biography, not counting the complete film list with both the French and US titles. Katz' enclyclopaedia contains only about 7000 bios compared to 12,000 in Halliwell, but I think he is correct in trading off the number of bios in favor of more useful bios. There are about 120 pages of appendices in Halliwell, many of which are both useful and unique to “Halliwell’s Who’s Who.” If you already own Ephraim Katz' "The Encyclopedia of Film" there is little reason to purchase "Halliwell's Who's Who in Film," except for some of the appendices, an expensive purchase. On the other hand, if you already own "Halliwell's Who's Who in the Movies," there is every reason to purchase Katz' encyclopaedia.
|