|
|
22 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Out of time, 30 Dec 2009
This review is from: Doctor Who - The Key to Time Box Set (Re-issue) [DVD] (DVD)
Doctor Who's first attempt at a story arc starts off well but ends up tired and out of steam. It is almost painful to watch the ideas (and money) running out in the final two stories of this season. That said, the first four stories are either good or very good, with the odd moment of greatness popping up here and there. Tom Baker is slightly past his best here, but Mary Tamm's Romana is excellent, matching the doctor in intelligence and arrogance, and generally adding a touch of class to the proceedings. As usual with classic Doctor Who DVDs, there is a wealth of extra documentary material that puts other lines to shame - why can't all DVDs have this much extra stuff?
STORIES:
The Ribos Operation (****) kicks things off with a pair of con-men trying to sell a slightly-used planet to a warlord. it's all about the writing here: almost every character feels like a real person, the conversations is delightful and a scene in which the outcast Binro's belief that those lights in the night sky are other worlds is vindicated is one of the best scenes in the whole series, yet it has absolutely no relevance to the plot. great, great stuff. The only fly in this story's ointment is the Shrivenzale, a truly awful rubber monster even by Doctor Who's standards.
The Pirate Planet (***), written by one Douglas Adams, is great-but-lightweight fun, with a scenery-chewing villain and a deadly robotic parrot to give K9 a run for his money. Adams was a man of ideas rather than storytelling, though, and this tale doesn't quite add up to the sum of its parts.
The Stones of Blood (***) is excellent in its first, Earth-based, half, but once the story shifts to Hyperspace it falls down into pedestrian courtroom drama. However the creepy stone monsters and the wonderful Beatrice Lehmann bring this to life whenever they're on.
The Androids of Tara (****) Doctor Who is never better than when it steals, and here it's classic film The Prisoner of Zenda that gets the treatment. There's a rubbish monster of course, but mercifuly it's over and done with in 30 seconds and we can sit back and enjoy this delicious fantasy of robots, doubles and, um, robot doubles.
The Power of Kroll (*) is one of the worst DW stories ever made, with its hackneyed savages-vs-developers script and badly-realised giant squid. Can the Robert Holmes who wrote this [word I can't say on Amazon] be the same man who wrote The Ribos Operation? Or did a stray robot double from the previous story wander into the producer's office during a tea break and thrash out a script when no-one was looking?
The Armageddon Factor (*) starts of intriguingly, but runs out of ideas pretty fast. Towards the end the Doctor sets up a time loop, in which events repeat themselves over and over again, and by the end of this you'll know exactly how that feels. The scene that wraps up the story arc end is rather too short to feel satisfying.
Extras (7 1/2 hours): there are so many extras here (16 documentaries, 9 commentaries, 25 archive pieces and a whole load of other stuff including the 1979 Dr Who annual) that I'm not going to list and rate them all. Suffice it to say that A Matter of Time (on disc 1), which discusses producer Graham Williams's time on the show (and this season in particular) is the most essential watch, Stones Free (disc 3) is a very interesting look at the Rollright Stones (used for location filming), and on disc 7 Tom Baker reads us some wonderful fireside ghost stories. The commentaries range from the sparklingly witty to the tired and dreary, while the production subtitles are as ever informative and helpful.
This box set is probably best bought after the price comes down a bit more, as the too-few good stories don't really justify paying full whack.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|