This is my first Zippo Lighter. The lighters I used previously were IMCO (Austrian!) lighters and they are pure workhorses. The Zippo arrived absolutely gleaming like a mirror, but, as one would expect with a solid brass case, after 3 or 4 weeks it's now rather tarnished... that's fine, although I can't find my brasso). The clunk is indeed fantastic. What I would say in comparison with the IMCO lighters is that the Zippo seems to go through fuel quite a bit faster and also that, in my opinion, the wind-shielding properties of the IMCO lighters are superior. Viewed purely in practical terms, the IMCOs are better lighters. That said, you can't beat the Zippo style, the clunk, the ritual flipping and closing of the lid - it does kind of add to the cigarette lighting experience (ha!). Lifetime guarantee with all Zippos, they are built to last! I am 100% happy with this lighter - I bought it simply because I wanted a Zippo!