Father Christmas gave this set to my 6 year old son and it has been a real hit. Admittedly he (my son, not Santa) is football mad but he has had so much enjoyment from it in only 4 months.
The quality of the players, pitch and goals is far superior to old Subbuteo (I know because I have checked with my collection in the attic). The players are better painted (12 are supplied in each team) and their bases are heavier making it easier for younger players as they tend to move straighter when flicked. The pitch is of a better fabric and sits reasonably well on the carpet, although it would be better to glue it to a board. However the goals are a bit flimsy and the nets tend to unhook themselves. Yes, two of our players have broken (easily fixed with glue) and a goal crossbar has snapped (again repaired with glue) but this is all part of the experience - tell a 6 year old that careless play results in breakages and he will play carefully rather than spoil a beloved toy.
This is a fantastic set for any child interested in football, they can play at their own level, using adapted or proper rules, and learn so much about the real game at the same time.