It seems that this simple song has invoked reactions of either love or hate, at least in those people which have reviewed it so far.
As to the slating/loving of the lyrics. To some extent I can understand where the slaters are coming from, but they didn't listen to the last line: The guy who 1st comes up with a plan, then thinks they shared this "moment", at the end realizes himself that actually he better get a grip and "face the truth". In that regard it is a good reflection on the reactionary way us blokes brains work when we see a cute girl.
As to the lovers of the lyrics perhaps they missed it a bit as well. It isn't a heartfelt song, its just the story of a bloke who see's a qute girl, his brain gets working as it does, then he comes to his senses.
As to the slating/loving of the music and voice. I think the music is fine, catchy etc.
So I will give this a good 3 stars. Therefore I am the first reviewer in the like it camp, rather than the love/hate...
I would still say buy the album and enjoy it (and life) rather than analizing everything and rather than being sentimental... Now I have offended both love/hate camps I will leave it there ;)