WWE presented "The Great American Bash" six times from 2004 to 2009. Although they continued to improve over time, something stupid always seemed to tarnish the rest of a good card.
In 2004, two Match-of-the-Year candidates were overshadowed by forgettable undercard matches and a murder.
In 2005, any good part that came out of that PPV was tarnished by a sleep-inducing main event that went on forever and ended with a cheap finish.
In 2006 --- as we'll explore here --- the whole event is comprised of switcharoos and last-minute changes.
I actually like the 2007-2009 editions, especially the 2009 PPV (which most people hate). But after this debacle, you'd never guess that "The Great American Bash" was worth bringing back.
______________________________________
1) WWE Tag Team Championships
Paul London & Brian Kendrick (champions) v. The Pitbulls
---For better or worse, JBL said that these four guys could steal the show. I won't go quite that far, but this opening contest was one of my favorite matches on the card. Jamie Noble & Kid Kash are equally as talented as the champs, giving this one a dose of Cruiserweight juice. It's a little slower-paced than you might think, but I've come to realize that patient action can be more gratifying. I really didn't like the 2006 "Bash", but I'll admit this kickoff made it easier to swallow.
"7.0 / 10"
______________________________________
2) United States Championship
Finlay (champion) v. William Regal
---The advertised Triple Threat Match also including Bobby Lashley didn't take place, but I give credit to the "SmackDown" team for trying to give this turn-of-events some depth. Lashley pleaded to wrestle, but was denied, much to the dismay of fans. Unfortunately, I was astonished that Finlay and Regal pretty much bored me from bell to bell. It wasn't because Lashley wasn't involved. It wasn't because both men were bad guys. It wasn't because the advertised match was changed. Quite frankly, Finlay and Regal were such amazing technicians I don't know why after three viewings I can't get into this one. It just moves at a plodding pace, and seemingly goes nowhere. Folks, I would pay to watch a Regal/Finlay match anytime, but trust me, this one isn't as good as hardcore fans want it to be.
"5.0 / 10"
______________________________________
3) Matt Hardy v. Gregory Helms (Cruiserweight champion)
---As much as I would've loved to see Super Crazy take on Helms for the belt, I have to admit that their "Judgment Day 2006" encounter didn't blow me away like I'd hoped. Besides, Matt Hardy and Helms have much better chemistry. This is a last-minute change that worked, in my opinion. With all respect to the dazzling athletics of Super Crazy, Matt Hardy was starting to hit his stride on "SmackDown" TV, and deserved some kind of PPV exposure. With the seesaw action we saw, I'd bet "SmackDown" viewers were happy with the result.
"7.0 / 10"
______________________________________
4) Punjabi Prison Match
Big Show (ECW World champion) v. The Undertaker
---This is the match that will probably make or break "Bash 2006" for people. As limited as The Great Khali was, his dominance over Undertaker was refreshing, in my opinion. I was looking forward to seeing how Taker & Khali would pull off this debut of the Punjabi Prison Match. After some non-sensical brawling backstage, Big Show as punished to be Khali's replacement. I strongly believe that even though Big Show and Taker had some good matches before this night, people were bored of Big Show once he became ECW's champion. But never mind that analysis, this match just sucks. It's just an endless barrage of punching, clotheslines, and slams...with some bamboo shenanigans thrown in. Both men bled and broke through a table, and the match still sucked. This is one of the most boring matches I've ever seen, and the storyline behind makes it even dumber.
"2.0 / 10"
______________________________________
5) Bra-and-Panties Elimination Match
Jillian Hall v. Michelle McCool v. Kristal v. Ashley Masarro
---I'm gonna catch all kinds of crap for liking this one more than the Punjabi Prison Match. But you know what, at least these ladies gave me something pleasing to the eyes. I dare say that there've been good Bra-and-Panties Matches before, but this isn't one of them. What can I say? Sometimes I like them, and sometimes they bore me. This one didn't do much for me. But I can't fault the ladies for trying.
"3.0 / 10"
______________________________________
6) #1 Contender Match
Batista v. Mr. Kennedy
---Another change to the PPV, as a 7-month buildup was derailed when Mark Henry got injured. I gotta admit that at this point in time, Batista was very boring, so seeing him go against a smaller opponent like Kennedy was refreshing. Besides, wouldn't you rather see loudmouth Kennedy get the crap kicked out of him, rather than seeing two mammoths just slug away? The big problem with this match is that it's too short, and that we didn't have enough time to care about the match before it took place. But for what it was, it kept my attention. Big props for the unexpected outcome, too.
"5.5 / 10"
______________________________________
7) World Heavyweight Championship
King Booker v. Rey Mysterio (champion)
---Thankfully, this dismal PPV is bookended by a very good main event. Say what you will about Mysterio's 1st title run, but he went out under very good circumstances. King Booker was quickly becoming an easy-to-hate villain, Chavo Guerrero's betrayal was cemented with one of WWE's hardest chairshots, and the contest itself was very good. Both men went back and forth, giving each other a run for their money. Even though these two squared off just days before their advertised PPV contest, it was still worth my time back in 2006. Unfortunately, King Booker's matches as champion were pretty dull, and the Rey/Chavo feud went into some distasteful territory. But at the time, I thought "Great American Bash 2006" came to a very strong close. I still do.
"7.0 / 10"
______________________________________
"Great American Bash 2006" is sandwiched between two huge problems:
1) Everything you wanted to see on this PPV didn't take place
2) Most of what resulted from this PPV was a letdown.
Seriously, think about that for a moment.
* The U.S. Title Triple Threat could've been salvaged if Finlay & William Regal, two great technicians, didn't bore just about everybody.
* The Punjabi Prison Match was a tough sell to begin with, made worse when Big Show was brought into the mix. I dare say that Great Khali and Undertaker would've had a better match together.
* Batista and Mark Henry had 7 months of history, and instead we got a one-sided squash. Also, Kennedy's victory didn't matter, since Batista became the #1 Contender anyway.
* While Booker and Mysterio had a very good main event together, Booker's title run resulted in some very disappointing matches, while the Mysterio/Chavo angle wasn't either man's best.
2006 was a rough year for the WWE. Want proof? Give this "Great American Bash" a look.