I've read some of the other mash-ups, like Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, Sense and Sensibility and Sea Monsters, and Abraham Lincoln-Vampire Hunter, but this one was better than any of those. The problem with those books was that the mash-up aspect was jarring, and not very well worked into the original text. And they were too over-the-top. This one is much more subtle, and works in the werewolf aspects of the story in a really ingenious way, so that the text flows smoothly, and makes for a much more enjoyable and entertaining read. And after all, Heathcliff had a very beastly nature in the original, so to turn him into a werewolf works realy well. It's not a completely ridiculous premise, like sea monters in Sense and Sensibility. And it all leads up to an ending which is really great. If you're looking for an obvious, obnoxious mash-up, then this might not be for you. But if you want something with a little more thought put into it, I don't think this one will disappoint.