Most Helpful Customer Reviews
16 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great introduction to the series, 15 Nov 2006
I have always loved this series of books since my Dad gave this one to me when I was about seven.
This book, although fourth in the series, is actually the best one to introduce children, uninitiated in the ways of sailing and camping, to the collection of stories.
The story focusses on the D's, Dick and Dorothea Callum, who are staying at the farmhouse of their Mother's old nurse for the Christmas holidays. Neither of the children know anything about sailing, signalling or any of the nautical pastimes of the other children in the books. So, when they finally meet the Walker and Blackett children, they are taught, along with the reader, all about those subjects.
For a modern child, knowing nothing about boats, the first book in the series, Swallows and Amazons, could be a little daunting, as the reader is introduced to that story through the eyes of the Walker children, who have already learned to sail and have a father in the Navy.
Quite apart from introducing the unusual hobbies of the children well, this book has all the elements of adventure and excitement a reader of Arthur Ransome would expect, as well as having the added magic of snow and ice! A great Christmas present for 7 or 8 year olds!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
30 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wonderful children's winter adventure, 1 Jan 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: Winter Holiday (Red Fox Older Fiction) (Paperback)
"Winter Holiday" is the fourth volume of the "Swallows and Amazons" series. It features the same Lake District setting as the first two but this time, we encounter the lake and its environs in the depths of winter, rather than summer. The book also introduces two new members to the 'gang': the D's. Indeed, the story concentrates more on the newcomers' activities, as they first meet and befriend - and then try their utmost to keep up with - the more experienced (and world-wise) Swallows and Amazons. Once again, Ransome allows the children's views of the world to dominate over the grown-up, outsider's view. Amongst other inventions, an old barn becomes a signalling station for communicating with Mars; the lower fells the wastes of High Greenland; and the frozen lake a training ground for an expedition to the North Pole. This is one of the very best of the S&A stories. It combines all of the fine features of the earlier volumes - beautifully simple (and yet never condescendingly simplified) prose, enchanting line drawings and an espousing of honest and open values - with an elegantly crafted plot and some moments of true excitement. It also has some cleverly disguised educational content, in the form of lessons in field communications techniques. (And the dangers of misinterpretation that can result from their use!) As usual, Ransome knows precisely how to build the excitement as the tale progresses. From simple beginnings, the book gradually becomes more and more riveting reading, until it is almost impossible to put the book down. It is lovely, too, to see how much the Walker children's characters - as well as their relationships with each other -have developed since the earlier volumes. Seeing them from the perspective of the newcomers makes one realise how much they have grown (and come to function as a team) in the 18 months since the first book! The world was a simpler place when this book was written (1933) and, sadly, the events portrayed within it just could not happen nowadays. But children of all ages can still enjoy tales such as this, to feed their own imaginations and help them to grow into the world as it now is. Who knows? It may yet help lead the world back to times as honest as these.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
23 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Childhood Revisited, 31 Oct 2003
By A Customer
I live in Maine, USA, on a lake with a small island just off shore (Wild Cat Island?). I live here because of my engagement with Arthur Ransome's books covering the adventures of the Swallows and Amazon's as well as the D's. I own the complete set in hardcover, and I am now giving them to my niece, nephew and grandson. I received my first AR - The Picts and the Martyrs for my 6th birthday, I have been an avid fan ever since. The stories are set in a timeless world. While the drawings show a prewar style, non of that time really affects the adventures of the eight children. In fact their childhood is what we would wish for our children today. Looking back I realise how much I learned from these books. In addition to becoming an enthusiastic sailor, I learned how to plan, to be 'pro' active and organized - Susan; that leadership not gender is what counts - Nancy; Research pays off - Dick; it's OK to have fears - Peggy; learning from mistakes - John; taking risks - Titty; dreaming - Dorothea; and just having fun - Roger. The stories are crafted so that we absorb these lessons over time but are not conscious of our learning. They are entertaining, most adventurous and should be on the 'must read' list of children's literature.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|