37 of 40 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
perfect for fans, 4 Feb 2002
By A Customer - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Wind-up Bird Chronicle (Continuum Contemporaries series) (Paperback)
OK, I should admit straight up that I'm biased - The Wind-up Bird is my favourite novel. So I'm hardly able to give this guidebook a neutral, detached review. In fact, I'm amazed that someone has published this - are there enough of us fanatics to make this kind of thing profitable?? I hope so, as I see that Mr Strecher has another book coming out shortly! Anyhow, this is a great place to start. It was good to read about Murakami's views on other Japanese writers, his student days, and his falling into a ditch at the age of three. If you've read the novel, that explains a lot! I thought that Strecher's analysis of the novel was wonderfully accurate, although as he admits himself, he has only scratched the surface of it. Especially fascinating was the section about the reviews the novel received - astonishing how many of these missed the point. In short, if you love this novel then I think you'll like this book. And if you haven't read this novel, please go and read it. Now.
25 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Understanding the Bird, 31 Jan 2003
By Daitokuji31 - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Wind-up Bird Chronicle (Continuum Contemporaries series) (Paperback)
I've read all of Murakami's fiction that has been released in english, so i am interested in anything that analyzes his fiction. This little 96 page book does quite a good job. It starts off with a short itroduction about Murakami himself. It is pretty short, and many fans would probably like to know more about Murakami, but it does help the reader to understand better from where Murakami is coming from and how his own personality is put into his characters. The second part of the book takes up many themes such as sexuality and violence. It gives the reader a higher understanding of Murakami's characters, and gives the reader an insight of what aspects that each character represents. The third part of the book is about the reception of the book in japan and in the rest of the world. This is a nice little book for a Murakami fan to read after he or she has finished reading _the wind-up bird chronicle_
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Useful little book, 30 Nov 2009
By P. Stern - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Wind-up Bird Chronicle (Continuum Contemporaries series) (Paperback)
I read this book as a kind of reward after finishing "Wind-Up Bird Chronicle" in Japanese. I wanted to check my understanding on a few points and get the views of a professional reader of Murakami. (I found Murakami's book enthralling and highly rewarding.) For these limited purposes, the book worked pretty well. Strecher provides a useful summary of "Wind-Up Bird Chronicle," and some of his own ideas are thought provoking. He also explores themes that run across many of Murakami's works, which I found helpful because I have not yet read much of Murakami's fiction.
But there is something small-time about Strecher's book: it treads a fine line between fanzine and critical study. There are a number of typos and other minor errors (e.g., the misspelling of "supersede" on page 20), and there is a breathless quality to much of it that doesn't really fit with serious analysis. It is fun, but probably mostly for the converted.
Two further comments on "Wind-Up Bird Chronicles." First, I don't buy Strecher's argument that Wataya Noboru represents Okada Toru's "other" self. (Page 51.) Likely one could make this kind of argument about most any pair of characters in Murakami, but this one doesn't seem supported by the evidence. I would say the opposite is closer to the truth. Second, I found it interesting that Murakami is quoted as saying, "If I were the protagonist, I would *have* to get my wife back. I would want to fight." (Page 73.) When it comes to Kumiko, I really wonder why. I found her a basically unappealing character from an early point in the book, and she obviously becomes even less attractive as things progress. So why does Toru fight so hard to get her back? Is it because the quest to free her from her brother and bring her home is the only action that gives his life meaning? Or is it because he has nothing else to do with his time? On this point, the depiction of Toru's inner life did not ring true to me. But maybe that is asking too much of such a wonderfully rich and evocative book ....