As a leading reporter from the Sunday Times said about this work; "It is not easy, nowadays, to write an original book on the First World War... but Preston has succeeded." My own view is equally as supportive in that I recognise a thorough and competent job of research when I see it and this book is at least that!
As I have said on several previous occasions, not all so-called authors understand the complexities of research. Such an undertaking is not just a matter of reading (perhaps translating) and understanding whatever information comes to hand and then producing an accurate and unbiased account, it is also a matter of finding that information - which might be located anywhere in the world and in any format. In the case of the Lusitania, four countries were directly involved; UK, USA, Germany and, of course, Ireland where she was sunk. Personal theories, expert analysis', political intrigue, survivors accounts, photographs, cemeteries, newspaper articles and official findings (to mention but a small number of areas of interest) are, therefore, spread far and wide. Add to that the passage of time (with little or none of the information being readily available on the Internet), and you might just begin to appreciate the amount of work which has gone into making this book an absolute triumph of dedicated research.
With almost 600 pages ofn text plus extensive index and bibliography supported by a good selection of black and white photos, cartoons of the day and press cuttings, this is probably the most comprehensive account of the loss of the Lusitania there will ever be. First published in 2002, Preston draws on hitherto previously unpublished British, USA and German archive material in a successful bid to answer so many questions which refused to go away after the loss of this magnificent ship on 7 May 1915 with over 1,200 of those who were on board at the time.
Why did Cunard ignore those German advertisements which warned that they regarded the ship as a legitimate target of war? Had Cunard been infiltrated by German agents? Was the ship carrying military, warlike stores? Was the ship armed? Was it the loss of the ship which heralded America's entry into WW1 or overwhelming public outrage? Conversely, was the Lusitania deliberately sacrificed in order to get the USA into that war to support the Allies at a critical time?
Those are just a few of the questions which have been asked over the years and I earnestly believe that this book is the one single work which will help every reader arrive at their own conclusions.
On top of that, Diana Preston is an author who has the gift of arranging words in such a way as to make the entire product a thoroughly enjoyable read and there is no better commendation for any book than that.
NM