If you pick this up in a bookshop you're likely to think 'wow, this is some amazing wildlife photography' and as this new 160 page volume represents the best in the world, the top choices of over 40,000 responses that is a fair comment. The thing is this is not a stand alone volume. Its been going for years and years. I think I asked in a review of one of the previous couple of volumes whether the increase in quality could be maintained or even surpassed. This volume answered the question for me and disappointingly the answer is no.
There is a certain amount of luck in any photo, especially in wildlife photography where timing is everything. You'd think it would all average out but despite the continuing increase in entries this year left me less impressed than the last 5 year's competitions, all of which I bought. Sure, there are some gems and if you buy it every year then I don't need to tell you that there will be some amazing photos in here, but its certainly not as good as portfolio 18 (Maybe the highlight of the entire series, to date) or the previous 3, come to think of it. Some of the photos seemed less than techically perfect in terms of focus and some of the black and whites seemed clumsy to me though maybe this reflected the tasts of some new judges. I don't know. I can only say that I was surprised that the photography in this volume was not better. I suppose I have been spoilt by the last few years where they just seemed to get better and better and better.
If you only want the one coffee table wildlife book to wow your friends, get volume 18, or 17 too if you want a couple.
I hope next year's volume 20 will represent a return to form.