Let's talk about emo/screamo music. This genre has one of the worst reps in all of the music industry, and it's not difficult to see why; A bunch of douchebags in skinny jeans with hair straighteners and low self esteem started listening to it, and then those douchebags that listened to the original, good stuff and decided to make an emo band of their own. Yay! And then more douchebags listened to that douchebags band and made their own band and so on and so forth. We are so far down that line of recycled emo/screamo/post-hardcore music that it's near impossible to even imagine that good music has ever, or could ever still be produced within the genre. But hark! Along comes La Dispute and takes a big steamy dump all over everyone's preconceptions.
The fact of the matter is that in whatever genre, no matter how bad of a reputation it has, there will always be a solid amount of artists still producing objectively good music within it. La Dispute are not the only good screamo/post-hardcore band around, but they are the last of a dying breed (or the first of a new batch, hopefully?). They make music that is sincerely emotional and depressing in the truest sense. The lyrical themes are dark and bleak, often focusing on the nature of suffering, sin and redemption, decay, internal struggles and struggles of interrelation.
The album is best heard in a single setting for it's full emotional impact. The lyrics are vivid and full of imagery, and contain a very poetic and lucid quality to them. They are told from the perspective of a writer, as many of the songs contain focused narratives which work as short stories, and there are four tracks spread throughout the album which act as the author's liner notes; monologues projecting the pain and anguish of his own creative process.
I can easily see a lot of people being turned off of this band due to their melodramatic nature and lead vocalist Jordan Dreyer's somewhat frantic delivery. Although these in actuality are the bands greatest strengths. Dreyer frequently alternates between hardcore screaming, singing and spoken word very unpredictably, as if he can't control his voice. He uses this absolutely masterfully, it's the kind of performance that has the power to make your hairs stand straight, but only if you let it. As I say, his delivery is not for everyone, his vocal inflection sounds similar to a lot of other really, really bad bands out there, however none of them have ever used this style to produce something this genuinely moving until now.
La Dispute have managed to create a harrowing tapestry of pain, anguish and suffering. The lyrics create a world where everything decays and dies, redemption is futile and hopes and dreams are for the people unable to take an honest look at the world. It is a work as painful as it is beautiful, and deserves full recognition for it's artistic achievement, regardless of it's genre ties, and should serve as a wake-up call that good art can be made in any shape or size (or sound!).