I read the negative review for this book and think the reader may have missed the subtleness that was behind the storyline. I think that if you had an Irish Catholic background you would have seen how true to life this attitude to anyone non Irish is. It is all about what the neighbours/family/strangers think of you as a family unit. The fact that the religious part didn't seem so important is that it can be hidden, but coming home with someone who is so different culturally cannot be hidden so is of paramount importance. I could relate to this so well, my parents would never dream of thinking themselves as racist, they had many friends of different cultures and colours, but would have never condoned them as part of the family. I doubt that the author is racist in any way, her humour shows that she is not, but she has brought to the fore just what living in an Irish family in England is like, I laughed throughout the book as I could hear my own family making some of the comments. As to Pierre's character not being explored - the book wasn't trying to give equality to both sides, it was just giving an insight to Niamh's background and family and he was the bombshell that was to be introduced into it. The culture thing works both ways; if it had been based in the Caribbean it would have had a similar reaction, but is only funny when you take the one character.
I found the charactors so familiar and loveable, the story was very funny and I found it a thoroughly good read.