No wonder Florida is so fawned over by real estate agents. This book is really pitched at them, and written in language that even they can understand. It doesn't even come close to being a serious study of the issues or an analysis of the data.
Regardless of the (many) methodological flaws, the logical ones are considerably worse: by Florida's own admission, it turns out that people can be (and are) happy living just about anywhere. Forget the dramatic suggestions that a third of people don't like where they live: a third of people just don't like anything except not liking things, places or people...And that cities around the world, even nasty ones that I hate (like Toronto) don't decline that quickly or inexorably, because there is money to be made in their regeneration. Or that his branded cities have a shelflife (been to Barcelona recently? 21st century version of Florence these days, after having been hyped to death as a creative place and now fatally dependent on tourism rather than creativity to make ends meet). Or that most people in the great cities of the world were actually born there, and not speaking the language is going to mean a huge investment if you want to live in Prague or Paris.
But what is truly obnoxious about this book is the way it seeks to add to the pressure and paranoia of modern living. Not only should you be worried that you have married the wrong person, work in the wrong profession, are bringing up your kids wrong, wearing the wrong clothes or using the wrong technology. Florida wants to make you even more anxious by threatening you that you have made the wrong investment in time, money and energy in the city that you, loser, have chosen to inhabit. Your lack of thought about this matter shows how much you need people like Florida to explain the complexities of modern living to you. In small words.
A treasure trove of banalities for realtors, a superficial primer for city planners and a means of inducing panic in Americans who can no longer think for themselves, this has the wrong tone and the wrong ideas about place.