I bought this book based on the beautiful pictures and the variety of recipes shown. I bake, my guy is the cook of the house who happens to be from Maine, so he is pretty familiar with the Whoopie Pie. He seemed unimpressed with the book, but he's a chef and doesn't use recipes. My first attempt at the basic whoopie pie started off strong. The cakes came out well but when I attempted the filling, I got nothing but a sticky gooey mess. It was way too loose to pipe onto anything so my guy had to bail me out and whipped up a tasty butter cream frosting which I used successfully. Undeterred I tried again this weekend. I thought the problem was that I had used marshmallow creme not "Fluff" so I made that change. Same result.
It seems that more effort went into making a beautiful book rather than testing the recipe. After wasting time and resources on two attempts at what should have been a pretty straightforward recipe, it makes me wonder if I need to invest any more time on any of the other recipes in the book. Too bad, because they all look pretty tasty. but I guess that credit is due to a talented food stylist.
I gave two stars because the cakes, with adjustment (lessened the salt), did come out rather well.