34 of 36 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Best Rock Movie Ever?, 7 May 2004
This review is from: The Who -- The Kids Are Alright Special Edition (2 discs) [DVD] (DVD)
One of the first, but still one of the very best rock movies. This non chronological approach to the history of The Who was originally fortuitously released at exactly the right time following the death of Keith Moon, which signalled for many the death of The Who itself.
The balance of speech and music is just right. Pete Townshend was always one of rock's most interesting interviewees and Moonie's natural wit is evident from the opening sequence featuring the band's legendary appearance on the Smothers's Brother's show, and reaches full fruition on the wonderful Russell Harty interview sequence, snatches of which are scattered throughout the film.
The music naturally speaks for itself, and unlike modern videos it isn't interrupted by speech. Also unlike even more modern videos the viewer isn't sent dizzy by cameras cutting ridiculously from one shot to the other every two seconds - see the Coldplay Live for a prime example of this irritating tendency.
I have loads of music DVD's, including recent ones by the likes of the aformentioned Coldplay, U2, REM, Red Hot Chilli Peppers -decent bands all. However, it was only when I saw 'The Kids Are Alright' again that I remembered that despite the often incredible modern special effects, the modern filming, and the modern hype, that ultimately non of these bands could actually hold a candle as a live act to The Who in their heyday.
The only other music videos which can even be compared to this are: The Beatles Anthology, as classy a product as everything associated with the Fabs; the Rolling stones Four Flicks, although great as this is I'd still have preferred a really good video of the Stones in their prime (when are they going to release 'Gimme Shelter' in the UK?), Led Zeppelin's DVD, musically fabulous, but Zep never had anything like the wit, warmth and personality of The Who, and The Who's other essential video 30 Years Of R n B, although this contains too much post Moon stuff.
No, for me 'The Kids Are Alright' remains just about the greatest rock music film ever.
The superior sound and picture quality on this DVD release, together with the second disc of extensive and interesting extras, makes it worth buying even for those of you who like me have the old VHS version.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The best Who dvd available!!!, 30 Mar 2005
This review is from: The Who -- The Kids Are Alright Special Edition (2 discs) [DVD] (DVD)
I too had the video, but the extra material made me opt for the dvd as well. I'm glad I did. The dvd is exceptional in terms of quality and sound. It shows how poor the video was. Even the laserdiscs were copied from the VHS and so were 3rd generation copies.
In the extras there are multi angle cams on WGFA and Baba which are incredible to watch. The film/video editing of WGFA left so much of the action out (Daltery's mike swinging , Townshend's usual menacing presence). With 6 different angles you have the complete view and experience. AMAZING!!!
A must for any Who Fan!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Kids Are Better Than Ever, 29 April 2004
This review is from: The Who -- The Kids Are Alright Special Edition (2 discs) [DVD] (DVD)
one of the Special Features displays the differences between the "old" andrestored sound and picture quality, and I have to say there's radicalimprovement. Best of all is the comparative clarity of the new picturewith rich colours.
The sound has been bettered too, and mostimportantly the tape speed adjustments make the Who sound like themselvesintstead of Chipmunks.
The optional subtitles are a big help too, for us foreigners and those whocan't quite keep up with the zanier interview moments.
The package isvery attractive and come with an illustrated booklet of liner notes.
More on the Special Features: they're a plenty, ranging from "makingof"-type of features to Trivia Games. A remarkable section is dedicated tothe musical genius of John Entwhistle: marvel at his bass virtuosowatching him in action and listening to a separated bass feed. Brilliant!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No