The White Ribbon [DVD] [2009]

 

 

Create your own review

I studied German at university, so I found this film to be familiar - the seriousness of the drama, the social hierarchy and the upright milieu of the baronial class, set against peasants and professionals. I'm used to Haneke creating contemporary drama, so this period piece was a bit of a surprise, it unfolds quite slowly, some of it doesn't make sense, there are lots of characters to follow.

Twice while I was watching this film, I had somewhere else to go, but I couldn't move. I found the tale to be spellbinding. You've got to have a taste for angst, horror and depravity, which tend to be Haneke's signature themes, but as in Cache or Code Unknown, Haneke evokes something painful about the human condition, the misunderstandings, the brutality and the lack of knowledge of other people's motives and actions.

I can see why some people would hate it. The film shows you of the cruelty of parents, the shame of childhood sexuality, adult sexual abuse of children and the reality of profound unhappiness, and Haneke does it in very raw ways. It's very like a Thomas Hardy story, which remains unsatisfyingly unresolved. Like Ravel's Pavane pour une infante defunte, this film leaves you with a depression that lingers for days. But good depression, which leads to a more profound understanding of life.

This is a film that will divide opinion between those who are firm advocates and those who wonder what all the fuss is about.

It is stunningly shot in black and white and well acted particularly by the children. It's a convincing film whose camera shots convey menace and evil in a way that is unsettling.

The story of a small German village and the appalling sequence of events that touch all the lives there is told through the schoolmaster. What do the atrocities mean? Who is the perpetrator? What part do the children play?

Given the adults are almost all unsavoury (one encounters abuse of all types) it is not surprising that the children grow up in a peculiar fashion. There will be parallels drawn between village life and the Nazis (indeed it's not hard to see one of the girls as a future concentration camp guard), but the film works well as a portrayal of an insular community turning in on itself.

Those who like their films neatly wrapped up with solutions will be disappointed. It provides no such comfort. But the conclusion of the film left me thoughtful and I returned to it days later to puzzle out what I thought about it. I'm still not entirely sure, but is it worth seeing? Yes indeed.

Before you start to read this, please note that it will give away some of the plot. I thoroughly recommend the film, and suggest you watch it without any preconceived ideas.

This film is extraordinary with myriad levels of interest. As an insight into rural lifestyles of the era it is fascinating (it would seem German agricultural production was much more labour-intensive and much less mechanised than in Britain at the same time, although probably it's wrong to make generalisations from the depiction of events on just one estate). It clearly shows how society was stratified into aristocracy (the Baron and Baroness), the educated elite (the doctor, the pastor & the teacher) the somewhat educated higher-level servants (the steward and the nanny) with uneducated agricultural labourers at the bottom of the pack.

Visually, the film is stunning; there is tremendous attention to detail in terms of costumes and architecture (just occasionally an over-modern window frame creeps in). Time and time again, there are beautifully composed shots of the village, the fields and the estate. The interiors of the houses are particularly noteworthy. When the peasant farmer goes into his bedroom to see his just-dead wife, the bareness and unevenness of the walls is indescribably depressing. The interiors of the other homes have been recreated entirely in keeping with the station of the owner.

The two above points, however, are not the main reason for watching the film (they are sort of extra "treats", if you like). A series of sinister events leads to closer scrutiny of the characters mentioned above. The doctor is found to be exploiting the midwife in the most brutal and callous fashion, and in addition seems to be abusing his daughter (whose age - 14 - he needs reminding of); the pastor is exceptionally strict on his several children, especially in respect of sexual matters (I do not doubt he loves them, and genuinely believes he is acting in their best interests); the Baron, while perhaps not directly responsible for the death of a disabled female worker, is most certainly exploiting the very poor agricultural labourers. The women in this film are all in the shadow of their husbands and their lives fall completely into conventional roles. At one stage, the midwife tries to stand up to the doctor & the Baroness tries to stand up to the Baron (but we don't know what the outcome of their rebellions was).

Children are central to this film, and it takes some effort to untangle them and work out which belong to which parents (principally the doctor, the steward & the pastor). This creates almost a pack identity, perhaps. Some of the events are harrowing; the pastor's confrontion with Martin; when Martin asks his brothers to untie him; when Anni tells Rudi that her father has pierced her ears; when Karli is being treated by the doctor. Other scenes are touching; I found all the scenes with Eva the nanny to be just beautiful. The first time the teacher saw her, searching for a premise on which to get her to stop and talk to him, he asks if she would take a fish to his father. This is despite the facts that neither of them has anything in which to wrap the fish, and Eva does not know the teacher's father. The exchanges between the two were always beautifully scripted and never awkward. No-one in the cinema noticed the comedy turn provided by Eva's father when the teacher went to visit Eva in her own home - I think perhaps it took them off guard, given the generally dark tenor of the film.

My only "gripe" with the film would perhaps be that the voice of the narrator was very different to that of the teacher as a young man. I was nearly annoyed by the one or two longish pauses - obviously the director had his reasons for these, but I can see that some people will not like them.

There has been speculation that the film prefigures the development of national socialism in Germany. Hindsight is a wonderful thing; the film takes place around 1913/14, Hitler was elected in 1933; of these two things we are sure. Whether the three key poisonous ingredients in this film (exploitation of the poor by the rich & powerful; repression, of children in particular; male dominance of women) led directly to national socialism is not, for me, certain.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 58 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

 

5.0 out of 5 stars A Magnificent Blu-ray Presentation for this Recent German 'Horror' Film of a Story Occurring in the Early 1900s
'The White Ribbon' is a 2009 film from Austrian director/writer Michael Haneke, of who's work which I've seen ('Hidden' and 'The Piano Teacher') has consistently managed to... Read more

Published 1 month ago by Mr. Laurence Williams

4.0 out of 5 stars Disturbing
As Haneke said in the interview contained on the disc he had been writing this for some time. It does have a feeling that it has been cut down slightly but that does not mean that... Read more

Published 5 months ago by D. J. Andrews

5.0 out of 5 stars A truly adult film, in the best possible sense of the expression
The White Ribbon won't appeal to those wanting a slick, colourful, fast-moving, gimmicky, loud sort of film with a few easy-to-digest plotlines, tidily resolved by the end... Read more

Published 7 months ago by A Satisfied-Customer

3.0 out of 5 stars too much for me...
I love a good bleak the world is damned, sins of the fathers style film but this was all a bit too much. Read more

Published 8 months ago by T.Harris

2.0 out of 5 stars rambled on
Most of the film was beautifully shot and very well acted - however it rambled on like mad - I very nearly didn't bother finishing watching it but managed to peservere (to little... Read more

Published 10 months ago by Cge Woodhead

5.0 out of 5 stars Spellbounding!
I found it to be very powerful! A very engrossing film. Powerful performances. Amazing cinematography. The story hypnotised me. The film ended without resolution. Read more

Published 11 months ago by Mr. N. R. Partridge

5.0 out of 5 stars the white ribbon
purchased this item for a friend who saw it once and said it was the best film he'd seen.
Great price arrived on time would deal with sellar again

Published 11 months ago by emma

5.0 out of 5 stars Very good film
Pretty much everything appealed to me in this film. The German spoken by the narrator, the acting, especially the way actors interacted with each other, the vicious children, the... Read more

Published 11 months ago by Calibandar

5.0 out of 5 stars Haneke triumphs again
If you don't know Haneke's work, try this. It is absolutely stunning, from the incisive, eloquent black and white photography, perfectly edited with fascinating use of framing,... Read more

Published 12 months ago by J. Jacques

2.0 out of 5 stars the story with no end or joy
I don't remember when the last time I was giggling hysterically after the movie viewing.. ever...this one did it to me. Read more

Published 12 months ago by Irina Polyviannaia

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 58 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

Search Listmania!