NOTE: This review is for the Western Digital Scorpio Blue 120GB EIDE 8MB cache Internal OEM.
I've been the happy owner of Dell Inspiron 8600 laptop for the past 7 years. A very nice machine, it has always worked flawlessly. For the past couple of years, however, the internal IDE hard drive performance has been steadily deteriorating. A very good HD at the time (Hitachi Travelstar 7200rpm), in the past months has become so noisy and slow as to make computer usage almost impossible. Firefox loaded in no less than 3 minutes, and let's not even talk of Photoshop, etc. The crucial detail here is that I was pretty sure that the WHOLE laptop had become inadequate: I felt that not enough RAM (I have 1GB), maybe a too slow processor, etc. were making my computing experience a nightmare.
So I was about ready to prepare a funeral to my trustworthy companion and was already looking at the Dell website for new laptops offers, when I stumbled upon this WD Scorpio IDE 120GB. Reviews were encouraging, installation seemed pretty easy, and 40£ wouldn't hurt the wallet too much. It came in pretty quickly. I should also report that, as another reviewer pointed out, it came in really poorly packed (small padded bag..this is precision electronics!!) from the amazon merchant kikatek. Luckily though, nothing went wrong.
Well I'm happy to report that I'm incredibly satisfied with the product: I'm no tech expert but I managed to install the hard drive in a matter of minutes. It was then a matter of a couple of hours to perform a clean install of Windows XP and Ubuntu (but there are tools out there to back up your former OS and dump it on the new hard drive for an exact copy of your work environment should you prefer this).
The difference can be only defined as astounding. These must be the best 40£ I've ever spent on pc components. Believe me when I say that now it feels like my computer is living a second youth:
-The WD Scorpio is INCREDIBLY quiet to start with, there is simply no comparison with my former hitachi hd. I can only hear a *faint* clicking when the primary fan is off and I'm my room in silence at night. The things is, this laptop is now more silent than it was when I originally bought it.
-while working at only 5400rpm, it operates smoothly and effortlessly. Everything loads faster then on the old 7200 hitachi hd. I no longer have time to go in the kitchen and prepare a cup of espresso before I finally get to see my homepage on firefox.
-The size of this WD Scorpio is double the size of my former internal hd. This is nice: while I wasn't craving for more hd space (in an era of external hds and pendrives everywhere, I was quite happy with what I had) it's a welcome addition.
-No problems with BIOS recognition whatsoever (revision A14).
I hope I managed to convey that I believe buying this WD 120gb scorpio was a wise move that will hopefully prolong the life of this "granddad-ptop" for at least another year.
NOTE: in my case, the major performance bottleneck was the HD. Some people with old laptops and less than 1GB RAM might want to consider a RAM update as well.