11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Mediocre sequel to excellent original, 15 July 2005
This novel continues the story of the `ship' begun in the excellent "Marrow". Unfortunately one gets the impression that the author has rather run out of new ideas. It feels much like part of an episodic serial in which the cast battle villain-of-the-week, complete with tidy resolution (reminiscient of an up-market novelisation of the Space1999 TV-series). The cast is familiar (plus a few `guest stars') and the BIG SECRETS of the ship lurk in the background as constant plot elements without being developed at all - the state at the end of the novel is pretty much as it was at the beginning.
Hopefully the author will tie it all up spectacularly in the (inevitable) third novel rather than have it morph limply into an interminable saga.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
One expected better, 1 Mar 2007
Reed is a stylist. Claiming to have no influences in the SF canon, the Nebraska-based author is very much and individual voice, although there are echoes of Simak in some of his early work.
Since `Marrow', sales of which elevated Reed's profile to the level of best-selling SF author (rather than modestly selling quality SF writer) his books have moved away from mid-America based (yet complex) slow moving tales to a form of post-cyberpunk space opera.
Here, in this sequel to `Marrow', Reed once more employs one of his favourite devices, the near-immortal superhuman, or rather, an entire population of them, travelling through space on a ship the size of Jupiter which has an entire world entombed in its core.
The Great Ship, as it is known, attracts the attention of the polyponds, separate parts of a gestalt Gaian entity which inhabits an entire nebula.
Reed's style here is deeply poetic, stylistically romantic and oddly appropriate for the society he has created. Near-immortal humans on the Great Ship see little change and neither does their society. The almost baroque style seems therefore entirely apt.
Reed is not an author prone to writing sequels, having only done it once before in his career to my knowledge, and one does have to ask how much the conception of `Well of Stars' was influenced by the success of `Marrow'.
Reed occasionally has a problem with ending his novels, and he seems to have left this open for a third voyage on the Great Ship. The ending provided here is somewhat unsatisfying and relies rather too much on a convenient plot twist.
Having said that, his work is generally superior to most other contemporary SF and this is a genuinely decent novel, but one feels that he could have done better, since this is not up to the quality of 'Marrow'.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Epic!, 8 Sep 2011
Having first read 'Marrow' and then the reviews to 'The Well of Stars', I was a bit reluctant to delve into the latter, for fear that the magic of the first book would be somehow compromised. Having just finished it, though, I am glad I took that second step. I found the build-up of the tension excellent to the last minute (indeed better than 'Marrow'), and I must say that the 'villain' this time kept me thrilled (and guessing) with its various manouvres. I did feel some story 'threads' could have been developed more, but knowing the end now, I expect this to happen in the third book (indeed intevitable!). I'm not going to reveal the plot or what happens in the end (or whether the big secret constantly hinted at is explained and to what degree); all I am going to say is that the Great Ship takes a real beating this time, emerging from it with a key change that connects the story with the first book and may help bring Marrow (the planet) back to the centre of events. On the criticism side, I did feel that the interesting ending was a bit rushed and underdeveloped - hence the missing star in the rating. Overall, though, a great read for S/F fans.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No