The premise of this book is that brands can be developed in very short timeframes which is contrary to everything effective marketers know to be true. Only brand 'awareness' can be generated overnight; the 'identity' of the brand (that is, the brand's image and personality that set it apart from its competitors) is created and held in the consumer's mind only through time and experience. To set a proper foundation for sustainable brand identity, there is no viable substitute for long-term planning even among technology brands. High tech companies today compete on brand identity as much as they do on technological innovation; thus to treat the brand in such a fashion as Winkler suggests is detrimental to responsible brand management. Anyone can `build' a brand but Winkler's advice won't make a brand `relevant' to anyone but the manufacturer itself.
Winkler appears to be a closeted engineering-oriented client dressed up as an (alleged) advertising 'guru' as indicated by her thinking. Among those in the business who are known for brand advertising that truly engrosses the consumer rather than treats them as lemmings, Winkler's reputation is far from exemplary. What's more, her agency's creative product generally lacks insight and understanding, which is the first place one should look before assessing the strategic advice offered by an agency-based author. I suspect the agency does not employ any qualified account/brand planners as I imagine they'd be miserable.
I am a senior UK-based account planner on loan to a respected creative agency in California with several high profile technology clients. Whilst I agree that time to market is becoming increasingly short, I know from experience that Winkler's advice runs contrary to smart advertising development. It's just a recipe for fast advertising development, and there's already enough of that in the world. What we need are breakthrough ideas, not just more of the same. And breakthrough ideas rarely happen overnight and they certainly won't evolve from such whiplash thinking as evidenced in this book.
If I could rate this book with fewer than one star I would have. For proper branding and advertising advice, read `Advertising and the Mind of the Consumer' by Max Sutherland, `Marketing to the Mind' by Maddock and Fulton, `Positioning' by Ries and Trout, `Truth Lies and Advertising' by Jon Steel, or `Under the Radar' by Kirshenbaum and Bond.