Most Helpful Customer Reviews
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A dystopian nightmare, 14 Nov 2005
This review is from: Warlock (New Doctor Who Adventures) (Paperback)
After a blistering start 'Warlock' seems to lose its way a little but salvages 4 stars with its ending. I agree with the previous reviewer that it is startlingly different from anything in the series so far and in many ways is not a Doctor Who story at all. Apart from the absence of the Timelord from the majority of the novel the sheer blackness of the tone and savage indictment of humanity on every level make it more akin to something written by Irvine Welsh. If you are an animal lover it would be wise to avoid this one - cats, dogs and rodents are brutally tortured - and the humans don't fare much better, particularly the hapless Ace. The depiction of a future dominated by the most sinister drug ever created (the eponymous 'Warlock') is almost Orwellian; I kept waiting for the nasty bits to turn out alright but they generally failed to do so; the depiction of the torture of a small cat did almost put me off reading any further but it is worth sticking with this one as it'll probably never be matched in terms of the way the 'Whoniverse' is depicted.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Amazing - A new vision for Doctor Who, 16 May 2002
This review is from: Warlock (New Doctor Who Adventures) (Paperback)
This story is absolutely amazing! I was gobsmacked when I first read it, there never has, nor will be a Doctor Who story like it. The story is set in a very dark and nasty future with some horrific events depicted. I adored the style and the vision Andrew Cartmell had. It's just a shame there will never be a Doctor Who like it again. This is really a sequel to the Doctor Who NA "Warhead" and features some of the same characters. I did feel that some of the characters seemed a little different than in the first book, but this is easily explained by the time gap between the two stories. You don't need to read the first story to appreciate this one, but it helps. After reading Warlock, I felt that Warhead was largely preparation for this (in my opinion - much better) book. The sequence of stories is concluded in "Warchild" which didn't seem as good to me. If you like dark stories, set in a very nasty future, get this. You'll benefit if you've read Warhead, but it isn't essential.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
"Justine never knew the rules...", 17 April 2003
By Andrew McCaffrey "The Grumpy Young Man" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Warlock (New Doctor Who Adventures) (Paperback)
WARLOCK is a collection of so many disparate ideas and strands that it stands as a real credit to Andrew Cartmel's skills and abilities that he not only wove them all together astoundingly well, but also managed to create a book that was engrossing, absorbing and absolutely unputdownable. It's another tome in his canon of bleak futures and stories where the Doctor is more a force of nature than a guy who bothers showing up in books that have his name on the cover. But its depressing nature is never gratuitous or overly unpleasant. I wouldn't like to see a whole series of Doctor-less Doctor Who books (the little fellow shows up even less frequently here than in Cartmel's previous book, WARHEAD), but when an individual story is done as expertly as this one is, that is a detraction I am more than willing to accept. The plot is a bit of a mish-mash when summarized, but it works amazingly well in execution. There's a strange new drug called Warlock in the neighborhoods of the not-too-distant future. The Doctor thinks there's something curious about it, so he sends Benny off to New York to investigate, while Ace wanders off into a sub-plot of her own involving hippies, sadistic henchmen, and animal testing. Some gangsters, drug-dealers, and a sizable dose of trippy prose all get added to the mix. Cartmel takes these pieces and hones them into a rollicking good read. There's something wonderful about Cartmel's prose. Ace spends several pages simply pottering around the Doctor's house on Allen Rd and it's absorbing. One chapter is entirely devoted to one man being ignored and it's riveting. Four whole chapters are spent waiting for cops to bust some drug-dealers and it's absolutely electrifying. It's one of the bulkiest Doctor Who books published at 359 pages, and yet the words just speed by. How does he do it? The characters again become something that Cartmel excels at drawing. Even relatively minor players are given intriguing back-stories and believable dialog. This is a more character-based story than WARHEAD was, which makes sense, given the more introspective nature of the storyline. The Warlock drug plays a heavy role in the plot, and many sequences revolve around the effects that it has on the minds of the users. These sections contain a lot of great writing, with the paranoia and other effects produced by the drug being very realistically portrayed. The portions of the story where characters attempt to navigate their way through the mind-bending and bizarre qualities of the Warlock drug were far and away my favorite parts. The things that Cartmel does here are quite chilling. There are some minor flaws. One of the themes running through the book would appear to be that scientific testing on animals is immoral and wrong. Whereas, all I got out of it was that scientific testing on animals is immortal and wrong if undertaken by a bunch of sadistic and maladjusted bullies. Cartmel has occasional bouts of playing too heavy-handedly with his themes, which would be enough to derail a lesser book, but isn't an unpardonable sin here. He also rushes the plot a bit at the end, which is excusable given the amount of stuff that he has going on, but also odd when one considers the large page count. It would be greedy of me to wish for an extra fifty pages at the end to give the story a smoother conclusion, but a four hundred page WARLOCK is something I'd leap at the chance to read. But these really are minor grumbles in a story that I hugely enjoyed. While WARLOCK is technically billed as a sequel to WARHEAD, everything you need to know from that book is explained here. So if you haven't read WARHEAD, it's safe to read WARLOCK. If you have read WARHEAD and enjoyed it, then I can definitely recommend WARLOCK. And if you haven't read either of them, then stop stalling, and get out there and read them both now. Yeah.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Groundbreaking Materal, 19 Mar 2000
By John Emmons - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Warlock (New Doctor Who Adventures) (Paperback)
For those of you who aren't familiar with Andrew Cartmel, he was script editor for the Doctor Who television series in its last years. He's written three novels, using the beloved Doctor and his companions. But be warned. His stories take place in a dark future, where he's not squimish about some grusome details. It has mature themes about drugs ( the title is the name of the drug), and so forth. One complaint from Doctor Who fans is the lack of detail for the Doctor. Although the Doctor is barely treated any more special than the other characters, but it adds more to the mysterious nature of the Doctor that Cartmel likes to show. What is the most important thing about Warlock is that it is a good book just as a sci-fi book. The ending is also a nice touch with something most people wouldn't be expecting to happen. Personally, Andrew Cartmel is very talented writer, and should consider writing more books.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Warlock: depressing and refreshing, 16 Jan 2000
By Ross Martin - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Warlock (New Doctor Who Adventures) (Paperback)
_Warlock_ is a piece of genuine Doctor Who. It can easily be criticised for being too dark or disturbing. While it is both of these, in the context of Doctor Who it is nonetheless valid. In fact, in my mind, it seems to show the limitless possibilities of the show's premiss. As a book by itself, it is first rate. The psychology of the story is well fitting, and the characters are well defined. The themes it tackles, while usually not found in most Doctor Who, are deep and interesting, and deserve to be explored in the context of Doctor Who. The plot is well rounded, tying together nicely at the end, with all seemingly loose strands brought together. The characterisation is also worthy of mention. Whether or not you like the characters is not at issue, it is whether or not you believe them. And in this, I believe that Andrew Cartmel pulls off something fantastic, that every one of them becomes part of you, of how you view your world. Overall, this book breaks new ground, not just in Doctor Who, but in literature itself. To quote the cover blurb, Warlock moves beyond cyberpunk in into a world where sanity is a matter of brain chemistry. It is a triumph!
|
|
|