Most Helpful Customer Reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Splendid Novel of Ideas and Action Set in an Alternate Recent Past, 31 Jan 2012
This review is from: In War Times (Hardcover)
"In War Times" is a great novel of ideas and action, showing why contemporary science fiction may be the most important literary genre of our time, grappling with greater clarity of thought and literary skill, the very nature of human existence, than what one usually discerns from so-called literary mainstream fiction. Katherine Ann Goonan's elegantly sparse prose captures vividly the vicissitudes of love, war, peace, and indeed, of reality itself. She weaves concepts as arcane and as dissimilar as the structure of DNA, the nature of time, and the atomic bomb, into one long elegant literary tribute to jazz, with each new unexpected development, as the tale progresses, emerging like some unexpected jazz riff played with ample conviction by the likes of Thelonious Monk, Dizzy Gillespie and Charlie Parker. Jazz is the perfect metaphor to describe what the reader observes in this brilliantly conceived, vividly imagined novel; the merging and splitting of alternate realities, of different future histories, as witnessed by compelling characters such as Sam Dance, Bette Elegante, Wink and others, especially enigmatic physicist Dr. Eliani Hadntz, who presents Sam Dance with the plans of a mysterious device destined to alter all of their futures. Goonan explores how time - past, present and future - can be altered by the least likely of events, sending her characters into different alternate realities that differ by the slightest changing of a few details, relatively trivial in nature, with important implications for the respective futures of these realities. Hers is a novel whose historical settings range from Pearl Harbor to the American crossing of the Rhine near the close of World War II, the Kennedy assassination and the anti-war protests as the United States enters the Vietnam War; it is indeed a novel of grand ambitions which Goonan displays via her ample heartfelt conviction and exceptional literary craft. "In War Times" is certainly one of the most notable contemporary science fiction novels of the 21st Century, and one that should be required reading by mainstream literary audiences.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Trying to alter history while stumbling around in the dark, 11 Feb 2008
By Rachel Thern "kiravae" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: In War Times (Hardcover)
At the outbreak of World War II, Sam Dance's mysterious physics teacher gives him detailed instructions for building a "quantum machine" that can affect human behavior and possibly change the course of history. The next day, he finds out that his brother has been killed in the attack on Pearl Harbor. This event sets his resolve to work on this device that may change the timeline and allow him to alter reality.
Throughout his WWII experiences he and his friend Wink try to build the device in their spare time, sometimes secretly receiving updated instructions. Their first finished device doesn't seem to do anything, but they continue in their attempts to make a better one. After the war, Sam begins to notice some curious anomalies.
This book was well-written, the characters likeable, and many scenes interesting, but I wasn't really able to really get into it or find it a page-turner. The characters seemed a little distant. I believe this might be because they have no agency - they are not controlling the flow of the story but reacting, having no idea whether their device will work and what it should do. When it appears changes may finally be occurring, they are still in the dark and so is the reader (one could argue that this is at least realistic - what character could get their head around everything?). History is finally presented as having nexus points at which it may be altered, but I found the choice of event the book focused on at the end to be a bit predictable.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Thoughtful, touching science fiction, 27 Jun 2007
By GadgetGirl - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: In War Times (Hardcover)
Goonan used to do more hard science fiction -- nano- and bio-tech. This is much more alternate history, and damn it, but it's good. Part of it is how well she's researched it (I read a review somewhere that said she used her own father's diary from the war), but a lot of it is how well she integrated what she's learned into the story. It's complex, and rich, and it rewards people who re-read books in a way I haven't seen since Tim Powers' The Anubis Gates.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Splendid Novel of Ideas and Action Set in an Alternate Recent Past, 31 Jan 2012
By John Kwok - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: In War Times (Hardcover)
"In War Times" is a great novel of ideas and action, showing why contemporary science fiction may be the most important literary genre of our time, grappling with greater clarity of thought and literary skill, the very nature of human existence, than what one usually discerns from so-called literary mainstream fiction. Kathleen Ann Goonan's elegantly sparse prose captures vividly the vicissitudes of love, war, peace, and indeed, of reality itself. She weaves concepts as arcane and as dissimilar as the structure of DNA, the nature of time, and the atomic bomb, into one long elegant literary tribute to jazz, with each new unexpected development, as the tale progresses, emerging like some unexpected jazz riff played with ample conviction by the likes of Thelonious Monk, Dizzy Gillespie and Charlie Parker. Jazz is the perfect metaphor to describe what the reader observes in this brilliantly conceived, vividly imagined novel; the merging and splitting of alternate realities, of different future histories, as witnessed by compelling characters such as Sam Dance, Bette Elegante, Wink and others, especially enigmatic physicist Dr. Eliani Hadntz, who presents Sam Dance with the plans of a mysterious device destined to alter all of their futures. Goonan explores how time - past, present and future - can be altered by the least likely of events, sending her characters into different alternate realities that differ by the slightest changing of a few details, relatively trivial in nature, with important implications for the respective futures of these realities. Hers is a novel whose historical settings range from Pearl Harbor to the American crossing of the Rhine near the close of World War II, the Kennedy assassination and the anti-war protests as the United States enters the Vietnam War; it is indeed a novel of grand ambitions which Goonan displays via her ample heartfelt conviction and exceptional literary craft. "In War Times" is certainly one of the most notable contemporary science fiction novels of the 21st Century, and one that should be required reading by mainstream literary audiences.
|
|
|