Yet another charity cover versions album, War Child: Heroes adds novelty by asking the original artists to choose who should revive their songs. The results are predictably mixed: Mick Jones' choice of Lily Allen to add sugar and cream to The Clash's Straight To Hell proves surprisingly inspired, while Paul McCartney once again picks the wrong woman, with Duffy suffocating Live And Let Die with coy mannerisms.
As with all covers, the best songs here revere the original (is there anything more dispiriting than an ironic cover?) but add a new dimension or perspective, As well as Allen's chimingly lovely version of Straight To Hell, her sweet vocal making the lyrics bite even harder, Peaches brilliantly re-invents The Stooges' Search And Destroy as sleek, dark electropop and Scissor Sisters streamline and discofy Roxy Music's Do The Strand.
Of the bolder cover attempts, only Duffy's Live And Let Die truly falls flat on its face. Presumably, slowing down this former Bond theme was an attempt to add Shirley Bassey grandeur, but losing its abrupt, playful shifts in tempo robs it of all its former charm. Rufus Wainwright fares much better with his medley from Brian Wilson's Smile, pushing his florid, elegant vocals to the forefront.
There are more straightforward revisitings, too. Beck's version of Leopard-Skin Pill Box Hat is strikingly similar to Bob Dylan's own honky tonk version, with a little added swagger, while Elbow approach Running To Stand Still with the same stately grace as U2. Sadly, TV On The Radio's version of David Bowie's Heroes is a mess, with its hard electro beats adding nothing to the futuristic perfection of the original.
War Child: Heroes is admirably more ambitious than many previous covers records, and the fact it succeeds so often is to its credit. But given the breadth of talent assembled here, you do wonder whether letting them turn in their own homework might have been even more satisfying. --Jaime Gill
Find more music at the BBC This link will take you off Amazon in a new window
titolo-war child. heroes vol.1etichett-avirginn. dischi1data-13 febbraio 2009supporto-cd audiogenerepop e rock internazionalecompilation----brani1. beck (bob dylan: leopard-skin pill-box hat)2. scissor sisters (roxy music: do the strand)3. lily allen ft. mick jones (the clash: straight to hell)4. duffy (paul mccartney: live and let die)5. elbow (u2: running to stand still)6. tv on the radio (david bowie: heroes)7. hot chip (joy division: transmission)8. the kooks (the kinks: victoria)9. estelle (stevie wonder:superstition)10. rufus wainwright (brian wilson:wonderful/ song for children)11. peaches (iggy pop: search and destroy)12. the hold steady (bruce springsteen: atlantic city)13. the like (elvis costello: you belong to me)14. yeah yeah yeahs (the ramones: sheena is a punk rocker)15. franz ferdinand (blondie: call me)