Most Helpful Customer Reviews
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Undisciplined and sloppy, 12 Mar 2003
This review is from: In the Wake of the Plague: The Black Death and the World it Made (Central Asian Studies) (Paperback)
I feel this title lacked the academic and literary discipline which you would expect of a scholarly work of this kind. The most negative striking feature I feel is the sloppy prose; indeed in one instance Cantor describes Eleanor of Acquitaine's second husband as a "young stud" (not even in my A level days would I have describes Henry II as so). And this example shows how the author meanders chronologically (he gives us a potted, and might I say slanted history of Britain from roughly the twelfth century, which frankly is not needed). Never before have I stopped reading a book because it was bad, but I would sincerely recommend the reader stear clear of this title. There are many other fine titles out presently such as Ziegler's 'The Black Death' and Cohen's new book 'The Black Death Transformed' which will more than adequately satiate any intellectual interest you have in the subject.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
In search of the lost editor, 18 Aug 2002
This review is from: In the Wake of the Plague: The Black Death and the World it Made (Central Asian Studies) (Paperback)
There may not be a mistake on every page, but sometimes in the course of this horribly frustrating book it seemed like it. When I saw that my 15 year old daughter had bought it to read on holiday, I was pleased to see her reading around what is becoming a very narrow GCSE syllabus. Sadly neither of us learned very much, apart from how much it seems European history has to be reprocessed for the simple-minded and culturally isolated US undergraduate and popular science market. A couple of examples: Thomas Hardy's works are transposed from Dorset to Devon (why even mention them as they come 500 years later?) and there is a horribly cocked-up timescale in the story of the downfall of a noble English family. The author similarly messes up the timescale of the events surrounding the collapse of Bordeaux, serving up a series of internal contradictions that can be identified without reference to source materials. He also views the motivation of people at different levels of society through a somewhat opaque glass of late 20th century complacency. My readings of history from those times - the story of the Cathars, the works of Chaucer, suggest that human nature and motivations have changed less than we might imagine, with the differences being the opposite of those he suggests. For instance, he accuses his characters of living solely for the present by contrast with today's mature and thoughtful readers, even though there was a universal belief in judgment and the after-life, and in many ways our own society can be characterised as shallow and materialistic. He also suggests that the English love for Edward III in spite of his allegedly unpleasant personality showed a cultural immaturity that would not happen today - Bill Clinton? Evita Peron? Charles de Gaulle? Mussolini? The examples are too numerous even to think about. A good editor might have made something of this book, although someone with such an exalted position in the academic world might not have taken kindly to some basic lessons in logic and research. Don't waste your money buying this book, or your time reading it. Buy chocolate instead - the wrapper is more accurate.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
DIsappointing, 21 May 2003
This review is from: In the Wake of the Plague: The Black Death and the World it Made (Central Asian Studies) (Paperback)
The first problem with this book seems to be that the publishers couldn't quite decide who to pitch it to - the mass market, or as a niche academic read. As a result, it falls somewhere between the two, thus almost guaranteeing that its reception won't be exactly warm as a pestilent fever. The second problem is that it really isn't that interesting. The text is largely dry, and will probably provide no new information to anyone with a general grasp of the workings and significance of the Bubonic Plague and Yersina Pestis (although the anthrax information is slightly more interesting - what there is of it). A quick, easy read, but insubstantial. I was hoping for significantly more.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|