Frequently Bought Together
What Other Items Do Customers Buy After Viewing This Item?
Product details
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
Customer Reviews
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
55 of 55 people found the following review helpful
This is a glorious and moving version of this great work. I'd previously not been stirred by my CD sets conducted by Jochum and Karajan (1951). Indeed, the latter version, recorded live at Bayreuth, is so highly regarded that I wondered if my lack of appreciation related to "Die Meistersinger von Nürnburg" itself rather than the recorded performances. Levine and his collaborators have now set me right. This DVD set is such a wonderful experience that "Die Meistersinger" has elevated itself to its rightful place as one of my favourite musical works.
I use the word 'musical' deliberately because it is the music that makes this special. Throughout Acts 1 and 2, there a flow of luminous melody that I'd not really appreciated before and which underpins the unfolding story. However, it is Act 3 that brings the musical and emotional peaks - the meditative prelude, the scene with Sachs and Eva, the entry of the Meistersingers, the delivery of the Prize Song, and Walther's acceptance by Eva and the townsfolk. The Midsummer's Day motif, first heard in Pogner's address to the Meistersingers in Act 1 and at the beginning of Act 2, resounds in the orchestra at key moments like a hymn to joy.
Those used to the familiar grand delivery of the prelude to Act 1 may find it here slightly underplayed. However, this matches Levine's emphasis on warmth and humanity rather than monumentalism. This is matched by the cast - Heppner a hefty but appealing Walther, Mattila a shining Eva and Morris an avuncular Sachs. All of the other characters are memorable in the right way, and the Met provides a traditional and pleasant setting, closely following Wagner's stage directions.
I have only one quibble with this set, and that is that the English subtitles are seriously minimalist. This is somewhat disturbing because one often hears the singers without any accompanying text appearing on the screen. An analysis of the libretto shows that nothing significant is lost, but it makes it more difficult to match words to music for those of us that don't understand German. This is the only blot on this otherwise magnificent set, and not enough for me to withhold 5 stars from my rating.
I use the word 'musical' deliberately because it is the music that makes this special. Throughout Acts 1 and 2, there a flow of luminous melody that I'd not really appreciated before and which underpins the unfolding story. However, it is Act 3 that brings the musical and emotional peaks - the meditative prelude, the scene with Sachs and Eva, the entry of the Meistersingers, the delivery of the Prize Song, and Walther's acceptance by Eva and the townsfolk. The Midsummer's Day motif, first heard in Pogner's address to the Meistersingers in Act 1 and at the beginning of Act 2, resounds in the orchestra at key moments like a hymn to joy.
Those used to the familiar grand delivery of the prelude to Act 1 may find it here slightly underplayed. However, this matches Levine's emphasis on warmth and humanity rather than monumentalism. This is matched by the cast - Heppner a hefty but appealing Walther, Mattila a shining Eva and Morris an avuncular Sachs. All of the other characters are memorable in the right way, and the Met provides a traditional and pleasant setting, closely following Wagner's stage directions.
I have only one quibble with this set, and that is that the English subtitles are seriously minimalist. This is somewhat disturbing because one often hears the singers without any accompanying text appearing on the screen. An analysis of the libretto shows that nothing significant is lost, but it makes it more difficult to match words to music for those of us that don't understand German. This is the only blot on this otherwise magnificent set, and not enough for me to withhold 5 stars from my rating.
73 of 74 people found the following review helpful
At last, the Met's definitive version on DVD! And once again, the Met shows us that you don't have to try to be different: just follow the composer's directions. Having seen most of the Met's operas that are available on DVD (and, fortunately, many of them at the opera house too), this one is definitely my favourite. The large cast is uniformly superb, the sets are as lavish as we've come to expect, and the constant dedication to the details is mesmerising.
Highest praise to James Morris, who is privileged to be playing the most likeable role in any Wagner opera. (The ONLY likeable role?) The security of his voice in the "big bits" is matched by sensitivity throughout - his Act II monologue is a great example. He's as fine an actor as Wagner himself could have wished to see as Hans Sachs - we love this guy! Karita Mattila actually acts the age of her character (late teens), which is a rare gift for any operatic soprano. All her scenes have a special energy. As our hero, Ben Heppner easily out-sings the Walthers of the two rival productions of Meistersinger that are available on DVD. Thomas Allen avoids the popular "caricature" of Beckmesser and perhaps brings more musicality to the part than we are used to hearing. Among the smaller roles, René Pape's contribution as a rather youthful Pogner is outstanding.
The sound quality is impeccable, and they seem to have got the lighting perfect this time. (One gripe I've had with many of the Met productions on DVD is the murky lighting.) The production also benefits immensely from detailed camera work - no where more so than in the lengthy song school scene in Act I, where we seem to be treated to characterisations of all twelve Masters.
I assume that Maestro Levine likes this opera - we actually see him singing along to the music during the prelude! His tempi are traditionally, as befits this production, with the exception of a rather brisk "Entry of the Masters" in Act III; instead of a self-consciously pompous procession we have the Masters hurrying on to the stage one-by-one in undisguised glee. (Sachs picking up the small girl as he enters is a particularly lovely touch.)
The one drawback to this production? From now on, I'm going to find it hard to take James Morris seriously as Wotan... For a modest price you get almost 5 hours of glorious opera. Buy this recording, watch it, and feel good about the world!
23 of 23 people found the following review helpful
Amazon Verified Purchase
The New York Met has produced some fine operas over the years, many of them, much to the delight of opera fans, are now available on glorious DVD. This is an example of what could be achieved with tremendous production values; a brilliant orchestra led by maestro James Levine, and a wonderful cast led by the veteran James Morris. Its a fantastic achievement all round. The lovely Karita Mattila is in fine singing voice, aided by Jill Grove as her friend Magdalene. Ben Heppner has a wonderful consistant tone as Stolzing although he may not look the part, he does sing with much passion and style. The well known Baritone Thomas Allen brings the difficult part of Beckmesser alive with much charm and humour. You cannot help feeling quite sorry for him during the climax of the opera. And of course, James Morris, who after his successful role as Wotan in the mighty Tetralogy Des Nibelungen sings the taxing role of Hans Sach with great determination, skill and much warmth. I do not think I have seen a production of Meisteringers which match Wagners production notes. I do think he would have been quite pleased with it. Picture and sound is very good indeed, especially if you have a 5:1 Surround System. A very good buy.
Would you like to see more reviews about this item?
Were these reviews helpful?
Let us know
Most Recent Customer Reviews
Wagner's Mastersingers
A DVD of an outstanding performance of The Mastersingers, at a very reasonable price.
A DVD of an outstanding performance of The Mastersingers, at a very reasonable price.
A DVD of an outstanding performance of The Mastersingers, at a very reasonable price.
Published 3 days ago by G R Hervey
Levine's 'Die Meistersinger Von Nürnberg' DVD
No CD recording of any complete Wagner opera is as cheap as this on Amazon. Customers who like Wagner must purchase this DVD because the production, the singing, etc. Read more
Published 9 months ago by Anonymous
A perfect "Mastersingers"...almost...
I don't really like to think of myself as a fuddy -duddy, but on the whole I prefer opera productions to be traditional and preferably set in the time designated by the composer... Read more
Published 9 months ago by M. Joyce
Thoroughly enjoyable, highly recommended performance!
I can't remember why I choose to add this DVD to a batch of stuff I purchased but I am certainly glad I did! Read more
Published 11 months ago by Mr. DAVID Geer
Sorry to spoil the party...
Since everyone seems to love this performance, I feel a bit like a party-pooper. But, honestly, this is seriously overrated. Read more
Published 11 months ago by Atavus
Die meistersinger
This is a very good performance of this opera.
All the artists are first class , both in singing & acting.
VERY GOOD VALUE
All the artists are first class , both in singing & acting.
VERY GOOD VALUE
Published 16 months ago by Bernard Akester
great music if you can get into it!!
Th quality of the singing and the music is as good as you can get but trying to get the disc to play is tiresome. my wife got it to play after I gave up. But I. Read more
Published 17 months ago by glyn
the best non bayreuth meistersinger
After seeing the real one in Bayreuth, this is a verry good second in place.
It is to see that the lightning was excelent. The players are very good and the sound in 5. Read more
It is to see that the lightning was excelent. The players are very good and the sound in 5. Read more
Published 17 months ago by H. M. M. Hoogen
Master of singers
A well presented piece of work, filmed with symphany for the cast and sets. The singing is atmospheric and of top quality - a good value DVD
Published 23 months ago by iaj
an excellent recording
When the DVD did not arrive two weeks after the estimated date, I informed amazon, and a replacement arrived within 4 days! That is service! Read more
Published on 27 Jan 2010 by Mr. Leslie Davis
Customer Discussions
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|
Listmania!
|
|
Look for similar items by category
Look for similar items by subject
Feedback
- Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
