I had an XBOX and now a XBOX360 and have always refused to buy a WWE game in the past as they have all been pretty dire on the XBox platforms as they have been produced by other developers. This game is from YUKES/THQ and they have produced decent WWE games in the past (for other platforms).
There are a few gripes...firstly the roster is not as complete as it should be, ECW franchise hasn't really been taken into account, the loading screens are only marginally quicker than on old-gen hardware. Even on easy level its still a bit difficult.
On the plus side the new analogue grappling system is brilliant as you don't need to remeber what button to press - and gives a greater variety of moves to each character, the hotspots are also quite easy to activate, the create-a-wrestler is very extensive, Xbox Live adds to an already enjoyable experience.
Overall this game is very entertaining especially on Xbox Live - but for people who have played previous versions the format is looking a bit tired and apart from the graphics and live play, there is not much to distinguish the next gen version from the previous gen version. The graphic do look great - although the dynamic sweat is not as good as it is in Fight Night and the divas lack any jiggle!