Steve Hockensmith returns with his second crime adventure featuring his, "Deducifyin' Cowboys," Old Red and Big Red Amlingmeyer and I for one could not be happier. Once again Hockensmith has given us a twisting, adventurous, thoroughly entertaining murder mystery that pays homage to the great adventures of Sherlock Holmes but which is never afraid to have fun with the conventions of those tales.
This time he decides to take the brothers out of their familiar territory of the open range and deposits them in a stand-by of many notable mysteries over the decades, a moving train. It's a setting that adds a new element to the story for the detectives, unfamiliar ground (and in the case of Old Red, the fact that is is MOVING ground adds yet another element, nausea!). Whereas in their previous adventure ("Holmes on the Range") they were in their element, the actual plains of the, "Wild West," here they are thrust into totally new, and not completely welcome surroundings both for them and certain of their fellow passengers, which adds even more depth to the story. Not only do they have to solve a murder but they must also deal with their own predjudices towards the railroad (which is destroying the farmers they themselves once were) as well as the predjudices of others towards them. After all, who wants to listen to a couple of scruffy cowboys playing at being detectives? Not to mention fiendish plots, mysterious travellers, an escaped snake, several attempts on their lives, a well past his glory days living legend AND a desperate gang of train robbers!
Once again we're led through it all by the wry, extremely humourous voice of Big Red, dropping in some witty asides, along with his brother, amidst the trail of clues and deductions, all leading to a truly exciting and rousing climax. The brothers relationship is what holds them, and the book, together and it is that added depth that makes the scenes wherein they discuss their reasons for being in a place neither of them feels comfortable resonate far more than you would expect in a book containing this many jokes regarding bodily functions (they ARE cowboys after all!).
It is a brilliant read, well paced, unafraid to mix in real emotional depth (though not too much to get in the way of the adventure), with old characters given new depth and new characters leaping off the page. Once again I cannot wait for the Amlingmeyer brothers to return and, "deducify," once again.