Better than Stomp 442 but still miles away from the heady brilliance of their early albums. John Bush now sounds like he belongs in the band and the overall sound is more coherent. It's just not filled with any truly great songs, apart from 'Inside Out'.
'Crush' and 'Catharsis' are very good without being particularly outstanding. To be fair, 'Random Acts...' from the inferior Stomp 442 was better. 'Inside Out' is the sure winner here. It recalls the triumphs of the past while remaining very 'nu-Anthrax' and it feels progressive, as if work has been put in. 'P & V' is ok but sounds like an outake from Stomp. '604' is nothing more than an interlude. 'Toast to the Extras' is another little surprise. Very un-'Thraxy but all the better for it. More like a breezy indie band than a seasoned thrash outfit, they strum through a jolly song that is actually very good and quite uplifting. More of this would have actually been good. 'Born Again Idiot' is ok-ish. 'Killing Box' could have been great but instead settles for just slightly better than OK, which is a shame 'cause it's a great song title. 'Harm's Way' is another good, slightly different, medium-paced curio that unfortunately has to pre-empt 'Hog Tied', 'Big Fat' and 'Aplha Male' which are neither here nor there and not much inbetween either. 'Stealing from a Thief' ends the album well as it is a very worthy track. It's just a shame that the hidden track isn't hidden on its own track space as you have to forward minutes of silence to get to it. When you do, it's (again) surprisingly good.
The highlights of this album occur when the band try a different tack. When they try to be Anthrax they fail because Anthrax no longer have their sound. Instead of varying degrees of success with changes in tone, they should have just said, 'Ok so we'll change completely and do a whole album of 'Toast to the Extras', and seen what happened. It would have been far more interesting than this hit and miss collection. Saying that, it is a better effort than Stomp.
And 'Cupajoe' is a pretty cool track.