Many approaching the option of getting this dvd-audio disc may start where I started, facing the store bins: Do I need yet another performance of this ubiquitous Vivaldi hit? The archivist in me said, no. The high-resolution thrill seeker in me said, yes. When I noted that the price was low, it seemed like a good bet for curiosity's sake.
Just a few minutes into the disc confirmed my delight and my surprise.
First of all, the sound is absolutely stunning. The surround sound mix tends to put you right in the middle of the orchestra, and the richness of all those strings is captured without the slightest hint of shrillness or glassiness or any of the other detractions we have sometimes come to expect from lower-resolution, 16-bit recording techniques. All you get in this version is music, music, music ... in such stunning vividness that you might find it difficult not to let the whole thing play through, right to the end, first spin.
The performances are brilliant and lovely, by turns. Vivaldi is being played on modern violins here, but in a chamber orchestra-sized scale that fits just right into the venue. The players acquit themselves without apology to period instrument bands who have also recorded this famous Vivaldi set of concertos; and while I do not see myself forsaking such bright stars in the firmament as Il Giardino Armonico (for example), this one earns its own place on the shelf.
If Naxos keeps up this kind of quality of sound with performance on other DVD-audio releases in the future, that label will quickly extend its solid reputation as a front-runner into the high-resolution sectors of the market.
Highly recommended, with five stars like rocket fireworks for all the sheer musicality of the sound that will be pouring out of your speakers.