Any anthology will have its [sometimes] glaring and controversial omissions and this anthology is no different. In this particular selection, the absence of both Lawrence Ferlinghetti and Gregory Corso immediately caught my eye and I'm sure others could add many more names to the list but, at the end of the day, we have to take the collection (now in its second edition) as it stands and not as it might have been. And, I would certainly have no hesitation in highly recommending this anthology as it stands.
However, I do have some quibbles and the first is the title itself. The majority (75%) of the poets featured in this selection were born before 1940 and more than half of the poets featured were born in the 1920s. Those who have survived are now in their eighties and, whilst I have the greatest respect for their durability, it does seem to be stretching the point to claim their work as the voice of `contemporary' American poetry. That's what it says on the tin.
The selection is also astoundingly safe and the biographies read like a procession of American poet laureates and literary professors in fifty seven varied but similar academic guises. In that respect, there is a sense that - rather like the
The Best American Poetry 2011 series - this is the American poetry establishment publishing and honouring itself. I do not get any sense of the full on vibrancy and challenge posed by, for example, the influential and still highly relevant
New American Poetry, 1945-1960.
But, these really are passing quibbles, I thoroughly enjoyed reading the anthology and for simply introducing me to the stunning work of Li-Young Lee I cannot recommend it highly enough. If however, you require an antidote to this parade of the already praised then I can do more than suggest that you turn to
The Outlaw Bible of American Poetry and the selected poetry of Charles Bukowski (
The Pleasures of the Damned). Bukowski, let it be noted, does not appear in this Vintage Anthology and he is even outlawed from the Outlaw Bible. How far left field do you want to go?