4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Good on food and descriptions, terrible on fact, 18 Sep 2003
By A Customer
I've just returned from the area covered in this guidebook, and used this (or at least tried to) throughout our holiday. While cultural information or descriptions are wonderful, (particularly on food) we found that, without fail, the majority of facts are wildly incorrect. I've lost count of the number of prices quoted that were plain wrong (although entry/exit fees, many guesthouses and travel tended to be cheaper than quoted here). Within three days we bought a second hand Lonely Planet, and used the Moon book for architecture, history and food.
When was this last updated? Not in this century.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Good on background but now hopelessly out of date, 4 Jun 2006
As with the previous reviewers who used this book in Cambodia and Laos and found it out of date, I found the same of the listings, services and 'getting there' sections for Vietnam. This country is changing so rapidly, with new hotels, restaurants, tour businesses, and even new roads, that getting around on the basis of this book was useless. That it's so outdated only 4 years after publication shows how fast Vietnam is modernising.
To its credit, the book was good on background and sites. Also it seems to be aimed more at budget travellers - not useful if you want to find the chic-est hotel or trendiest restaurant (of which there are many now in Hanoi - a gourmet hotspot if you're prepared to splurge).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
reviews posted by the author (buckeroo555@yahoo.com), 3 May 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: Vietnam, Cambodia and Laos Handbook (Moon Travel Handbooks) (Paperback)
***** Reviewer: David Stanley, Canada, January 30, 2000
AN OUTSTANDING GUIDEBOOK
I've been using Michael Buckley's Vietnam Handbook for two months now and have found it to be excellent. It's well organized with country introductions which told me almost everything I wanted to know. Michael's sidebars are intriguing and I especially appreciate the city walking tours which have led me to many hidden little places I might have missed otherwise.
The maps are better than those in the other guidebooks because sites are labeled right on the maps themselves rather than coded in a key which is impossible to read in dim lighting... Michael has provided not only the usual city and country maps, but also detailed inner city maps and even maps of the individual temples around Angkor Wat.
This book covers three countries and sure beats having to buy and lug around individual guides to Vietnam, Cambodia, and Laos. I've found that the coverage better than adequate and certainly head and shoulders above the general Southeast Asia guides which are surprisingly sketchy about these countries. Indochina is changing so fast that much of the practical information in any guide is bound to be out of date before the book reaches the shelves and this 1998 edition does require updating, but so do all the other guides to the region. You usually end up getting that kind of information from other travelers anyway. Of the three countries included, the coverage of Cambodia is the weakest, obviously because that country is only now opening to independent travel. Next edition Michael needs to get to places like Kampong Cham, etc. Meanwhile I recommend this handbook highly over all its competitors.
**** Reviewer: A reader from Boston, MA August 16, 1999 A good companion to other guides, esp. for sights and history. I used this guide for travel throughout Cambodia and in Saigon in the summer of 1999. I found it to be well-written and insightful, particularly about history, culture, and general observations about travel in the region. I found that I didn't rely on it so much for nitty-gritty details like accommodations or travel info (I used Let's Go: Southeast Asia for that) or for places to go out (I borrowed someone else's Lonely Planet for that). But I did come to rely on its clear modern history sections, its meticulous maps, and even its opening chapters on travel in the region. This guidebook is clearly thoughtfully and thoroughly researched. Although I wouldn't recommend traveling with it alone, I certainly was glad I brought it along.
**** Reviewer: A reader from San Francisco, California July 28, 1999
A MUST READ: As a seasonal guide in Vietnam and Cambodia for each of the past seven years, many people ask me how they should prepare for their trip to the region. I always recommend this guide. My work requires extensive research and I read a lot of guidebooks and this one is the only one with any decent accuracy and thoroughness. I also think Buckley is simply a good writer. Aside from Tom Brosnahan's Turkey guidebook for Lonely Planet, I think it is perhaps the best written one out right now. And I find his particular humor makes light of what can be trying circumstances and boring details. By the way, the current edition has been updated with a lot of information from as recent as 1997 (about as recent as you can get in any guidebook of the area published in 1998 I am afraid).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No