I bought this in a shop speculatively today, although you can get it cheaper than I did by buying it on here... To be honest I decided to purchase this 10 CD set of Victoria's music for two reasons. Firstly, although I am not really a renaissance music aficionado, of the late renaissance music I have spent time with, Victoria's is (for whatever reason) the most striking and moving to me. I won't elaborate on this here, as if you are reading this review it is likely you have your own assessment of these things! The second reason I bought it was a sense of shock that Deutsche Grammophon Archiv, a once splendid source, would actually bother to, or be allowed to, release anything like this these days. It is a far more risky commercial proposition than DG's invaluable boxes of Schumann, Liszt, and Chopin of the last few years (they were not that impressive when it came to Haydn and Mahler). Even the excellent but sadly very short-lived Messiaen complete works they released for that anniversary might be seen as a bit less of a risk, given the popularity of that composer in recent years.
As most of the afore-mentioned recent anniversary sets have overwhelmingly collected together previously released recordings this set seems even more of a mystery - only labels like Brilliant Classics seem able to whip up instant comprehensive new sets of anything these days. However, it seems, reading the small print, that these recordings are licensed from the Caja Madrid foundation. As I have recently listened to a cd of entirely different music from this foundation's associated label, it may be that some, at least, of these discs have had limited circulation before (the earliest recordings are from 2008). Perhaps some Spanish readers - or others - can clarify? This is not labelled with the dreaded 'limited edition' sticker that means you won't find it in another 6 months, but I'd be pleasantly surprised if it hangs around.
As for the performances, I have listened to about 5 of the discs so far and they are quite beautiful. Mixed voice choir, mostly unaccompanied but some works with organ or instrumental participation. Michael Noone explains in the notes that one of the criteria for what has been included is whether works have been recorded before and there are several Masses and Magnificat settings, in particular, that are new to the catalogue. Although the best known motets are here, and I'm listening to a beautiful performance of the Lamentations for Holy Week as I type, this is not a 'comprehensive' survey of Victoria's music. There are over *90* works here though, so I'm sure its the most comprehensive box of Victoria's music we are ever likely to get! The earlier of his two Requiem settings is included - which is good news, as the 1605 Requiem is one of the few works most music lovers interested in this set will already have. You will also need an alternative for some of the Holy Week music, notably the tenebrae responsaries. But, really, now- given the costs of one or two of the already-released (and mainly re-issued) Victoria anniversary sets from other groups- you get at least twice the music here for not much at Amazon's price, a substantial amount of music that hasn't been recorded before, and if you're like me, you also get to send a rare positive signal to a brand that seemed to have fallen from grace in recent years... Go on, you know you want to and you'll be helping out everyone who likes or liked the Archiv label as well.... Congratulations to the performers and to all involved: I'm still slightly in shock...