15 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Bravo! Encore!, 29 May 2003
By A Customer - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Venetian Stories (Hardcover)
I've been to Venice a few times, and Ms Rylands' book is funny and moving and most of all, gives you a real feel for the city. I think it's really sympathetic to the inhabitants. My favourite has to be the story of the Countess-a woman who is struggling against the collapse of her family and what she perceives to be the slow death of Venice, as tourism ruins life for the local inhabitants, who are leaving for the mainland. Like one of her famous courtesans, her beauty has brought Venice tourism and wealth, but at what cost?
Like all Turner-Rylands' depictions of family life, the outcome of the Countess story is very touching, and definitely optimistic. She clearly has adopted the italian reverence for the family.
...I don't know if these are real people she's based her book on as the Iowa reviewer seems to think (perhaps he/she knows something I don't), but it's to the author's credit that they seem so utterly real. If they are, I'd love to meet them...Venetian Stories certainly made me wanna go back to Venice soon!
21 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Venice was never this boring., 17 Oct 2003
By A Customer - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Venetian Stories (Hardcover)
I approached this book with great anticipation, having loved Venice my entire adult life, having visited it half a dozen times and having devoured a whole shelf-ful of Venetian novels, stories, poems and travel books--Wings of the Dove, Death in Venice, The Passion, Those Who Walk Away, The Comfort of Strangers, Don't Look Now, Dead Lagoon, Invisible Cities, the mystery novels of Donna Leon, the histories by Jan Morris and J.J. Norwich, and the classic book-length essay by Mary McCarthy. Venice tends to confer a kind of refinement on books about her. But not this time! I found it impossible to get into this book. I kept trying NOT to become bored, hoping it would get better, but alas it did not. The author's narrative voice is grating, arch, full of itself and hollow. She tries for lit'ry effects again and again, but all she achieves is affectation, which is painful to witness, if at times unintentionally hilarious: I mean, what on earth does "evanescence whispered in the walls" mean? Does the author understand the meaning of the word "evanescence?" It would seem not. Rylands betrays herself throughout her book as a posturing novice putting on airs. Stay away at all costs. You can lay your hands on enough real literature about Venice without wasting your time on trash like this.
26 of 35 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
A missed opportunity..., 18 May 2003
By A Customer - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Venetian Stories (Hardcover)
Jane Turner Rylands has lived in Venice for thirty years and, according to the jacket copy of this collection of short stories, her husband is the director of the Peggy Guggenheim Museum of modern art. One can assume therefore that Ms. Rylands is fairly well positioned to write a perceptive account of what really happens in Venice. The surprising and disappointing thing is how many of the stories in this book involve unpleasant people stabbing each other in the back and jockeying for social position.
To be fair, Rylands' writing is polished and she can tell a story well. But she has an annoying fatal flaw: it's her irritating condescension, which never lets up. Really talented story-tellers are truly engaged with their characters; Ms. Rylands' haughty tone sets her apart and puts the reader off at the same time. In addition, she often strains for effect with awkward or even downright silly results--as in the book's very first sentence: "When the last quarter of the twentieth century opened throttle for the millennium and the Venice of today...."
Rylands would probably have been better off writing a book of nonfiction about her own life in Venice and the lives of other real people who live there. But then, maybe she did and this is it.