3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Superb invention, far future science never seen before. Yes!, 1 Nov 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: Vast (Mass Market Paperback)
The review already posted complains that the characters are 'flat', but on the contrary I found them a diverse and fascinating collection of mostly post-human people of the extremely far future, and given their desperate situation I was engaged with their personal struggles and 'inner life', finding it all quite convincingly nonsoap opera... Also, far from 'drifting along', it was far more reminiscent of a submarine being hunted by an implacable enemy, with all the tense moments of hiding in silence and attempting to outwit the superior enemy.
The alien nano infestation on the hull, which was an emergent 'computer' like none other I've ever read about or heard suggested, was a brilliant furtherance of sf's tropes, and the 'human bomb' that had been created by the aliens from a captured exploratory crew and then sent into human society to spread a cult of charisma, but had been 'defused' by the crew who lived in uneasy alliance with their perverted friend was also a unique furtherance of sf, and a very affecting character in his buried lust to 'recruit' people to his cult, even though he knew he shouldn't, and also couldn't in the company of his crew because they had learned how to 'defuse' him... an extraordinary invention, and a wonderful character! There are so many other wonderful sf inventions in this novel, including the way the alien-altered 'bomb' discussed above was 'hacking' the alien nano infestation through submerging his head into it... sense of bizarre wonder in trumps! I loved this book! Read it!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent space opera, 11 May 2004
I read this book because I read someone elses rave about it, so here's mine...
This is an excellent and very hard sf book. The science is very futuristic but not fantasy (I hate fantasy and someone else implied in a review that it has leanings towards this). The ideas in the book are thought provoking and some are new to me. This book puts me in mind of others like Vernor Vinge - Deepness in the Sky, Neal Stepehenson - The Diamond Age. The ending may annoy some as it is not completely resolved, but then what is?
Characters are ok, some are skimmed, some are filled in, overall I think I'll remember a couple of them but not in detail. Didn't affect my enjoyment of the book though.
I would strongly recommend this to anyone who likes hard SF. Another one that makes me want to talk about it with someone else who's read it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Definately worth a read., 12 Feb 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: Vast (Mass Market Paperback)
This is the first book by Linda Nagata that I have read, and I think I will keep an eye out for her other works.
Even though Vast appears to be part of a series, I had no problems slipping into the book's flow. Indeed, I found it refreshing to enter the action straight away, though naturally it was a little harder to identify with the characters and some of the events.
The book is best classified as hard sci-fi - mostly of a nano/bio nature - although it doesn't contain the depths of scientific detail that some authors (eg Greg Egan) would include, and it only gives a brief look at how people might respond to the 'philosophy' of existing in multiple states (electronically or physically) at the same time, or modifying/editing ones behaviour and feelings.
Linda Nagata's writing style is 'free and easy' - one doesn't have to concentrate hard to work out what is happening, which is good because some of the action in this book would be difficult to follow otherwise. Her characterisations are a little flat - athough the characters do have distinct personalities, they don't seem to develop that much over the course of the book. This could be in part because the book is part of a series, or in part because the characters freeze or ghost themselves so often that they don't exist in an alive state long enough to develop. However, given the experiences and physical engineering they undergo, I would have expected more from them.
The focus of the book meanders a bit - rather than being on a mission to seek the Chenzeme (who are attacking human colonies and ships), one gets the impression that the whole journey is a river adventure - just floating along and seeing what happens next. Similarly, character focus tends to float too, to the point where some characters are almost forgotten or ignored. As such, we don't get to explore their inner self as much as I would have hoped, adding to their 'flatness'.
The story itself is okay, though nothing outstanding. However, Linda Nagata tells it well, and I am not disappointed with it. With a bit more character development and a tighter plot, this book would be pretty good.
In summary, Vast is definately worth a read, and Linda Nagata is an author to watch out for in the future.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No