I appreciate Jo Beverley's historical accuracy and attention to even small details of life in the time periods of her books. She has done a stellar job here of illustrating social class and gender issues in Georgian England. The hero, upper-class Catesby Burgoyne, younger brother of the Earl of Malzard, has just left the army and is at sixes and sevens in his life and at odds with his family. He meets middle-class heroine Prudence Youlgrave, daughter of a deceased librarian and sister to a lawyer, when rescuing her from thugs late at night as he is passing through the town she lives in. Prudence has come down in the world after the death of her father and later mother, receiving no help from an ungrateful brother, and is forced to live in a very poor, lower-class area.
Cate and Prudence end up married (part of the white-knight rescue) and Cate ends up as Earl of Malzard, after the unexpected death of his older brother. Prudence's struggle to be accepted into Cate's family is well portrayed and social hierarchies both below- and above-stairs at Cate's estate is a big part of the story. The characters illustrate the huge gaps in social equality, Cate's family feeling superior to Prudence and even Prudence at first shows some feelings of superiority to her lower-class, uneducated neighbors. Even within the servant class at the Malzard estate, we see how hierarchy is also in place.
In addition to the inequality issues, Beverley also supplies interesting minutia of daily life in 1700s England. Unfortunately, when reading this I felt that Beverley had set out to educate me rather than to entertain me, as though this book were her antidote to the myriad mass market superficial and anachronistic HRs we're being inundated with lately. I suppose for those readers who are getting their historical perspective only from that kind of HR, maybe this one should be required reading. It does supply more insight into how people really lived in the times.
However, this is supposed to be an historical "romance" and what it does not supply is a really good love story. The H-h relationship does develop slowly and realistically and this is good, but it lacks any heat and the warmth of the romance is almost tepid. I can live with a romance lacking hot and graphic sex scenes, but I do expect it to give me the warm fuzzies and this one failed on that account.
One more peeve I have with these more recent novels in the "Malloren world" is that they don't even come close to the original Malloren series in quality and romance. Yes, Beverley continues to write well but my interest flags in her more recent series. No new character compares to the Marquess of Rothgar or his wife Diana, the Countess of Arradale, and they are sadly underused in these books, putting in only cameo appearances.