7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Review by Neal Ascherson in The Observer, 19 May 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: The Uninvited: Refugees at the Rich Man's Gate (Paperback)
.....'Marvellous sharp-end reportage is a big part of this book. But what makes Jeremy Harding's writing so compelling is the way he interprets what he sees and hears. From Ceuta, he points out that the sheer horror of these immense desert pilgrimages fulfils, accidentally, a European requirement. It sieves out the applicants. 'These job seekers' says Harding drily, 'are among the most highly motivated in Europe.'........
In the same way, he goes down to the Puglian cast of Italy to watch the patrol boats chasing gommoni - the rubber dories which rush illegal migrants across the Adriatic from the Albanian shore - and finds that the traffickers can be brave and unselfish with their passengers as well as extortionate.......
And up the coast at the Regina Pacis refuge camp, he meets a defiant pries who claims that the illegals have only two friends in the world: his refuge and organised crime. Harding traces the history of what he calls 'Europe's project of exclusion', the slow slinking-away of commitment to the 1951 Convention on refugee status towards a new dream of 'Fortress Europe', which he bitingly calls a 'dreary pastoral fantasy, in which the European Union resembles an Alpine valley surrounded by impregnable, snow-capped mountains'......
It is now almost incredible to recall the way in which France, for example, simple opened its frontiers between the world wars to hundreds of thousands of White Russians, Armenians fleeing genocide, German anti-Nazis and Jews, Spanish Republicans or Italian opponents of Mussolini. Britain was generous too, once. Jeremy Harding suggests that the first real sign of a change came in 1900, when the SS Cheshire arrived at Southampton, in an uproar of publicity, with a party of South African Jews hoping to take refuge from the Boer War. They were depicted in the Daily Mail much as the same paper would describe Kurdish or Tamil asylum-seekers now......
It is ironic, as Harding observes, that those who passionately believe in the sort of globalisation which is based on the free movement of capital are equally passionately opposed to the free global movement of people.....
The first key to understanding migration is understanding that the distinction between 'genuine asylum seeker' (good) and 'economic migrant' (bad) is rubbish. In the refugee camp at Ceuta, Africans are envious because the Algerians pass the EU criteria of 'political persecution' and they do not, but they also consider - as people who have known real want and hunger - that the distinction between persecution by a state or a terrorist movement and persecution by starvation is utterly unreal......
The second part of wisdom is simpler: realising that in the end, legally or illegally, the rest of the world is going to get into this Sound of Music valley of ours, and that they will make it younger, higher-earning and altogether a less oppressive place.'
adapted from a review that appeared in The Observer on 7 May 2000.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
survey of national reviews, 4 July 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: The Uninvited: Refugees at the Rich Man's Gate (Paperback)
'A remarkable book ... succinct, witty and judicious.' Daily Telegraph, 10.06.00
'This short book should be required reading for all those who wish to reap the rewards of the global economy while ignoring the responsibilities that come with it.' Irish Times, 20.05.00
'Harding is sceptical about attempts to confine refugees in the same region of the world as the countries they are fleeing. Neighbouring countries are in many cases no safer . . . As he sums up in one brutal image, "the dead body of a 'regionalised' Afghan refugee on the road out of Gujrat is no use to anyone.' Unlike some armchair pontificators, Harding has seen enough dead bodies for this to be more than machismo. He scorns the language of euphemism and disdain.' Financial Times, 24.06.00
'A gripping blend of reportage and analysis, it explains the causes and outcomes of the "expensive game of wits being played along the frontiers of the rich world".' The Independent, 10.06.00
'I have forwarded my copy of this book to the Minister for Justice and if he has already read it, I would ask him to pass it along.' Sunday Tribune, Dublin, June 2000
'Heart-rending stories, cool analysis.' The Scotsman, 03.06.00
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Little book with a lot packed in, 14 Jan 2004
This review is from: The Uninvited: Refugees at the Rich Man's Gate (Paperback)
Very topical subject. Without turning the subject into a melodrama or a conspiracy theory, the delicate issue of clandestine immigration is finally brought to the foreground in an objective manner. Harding also reminds us that in the midst of all the discussions about illegal immigrants and asylum seekers, we are nonentheless talking about human beings.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No