I came across this book purely by chance while my daughter and I were trawling the shelves at the library. I've read about research that claims that having lots of books in your house is actually more indicative of your child's academic success than whether or not you read to them every night. Based on this premise I've been taking my daughter to the library every day and leaving her amongst the books. If the research is right, perhaps this will reap the rewards of private education plus the best tutoring money can buy without all of the expense...
Clearly I don't actually do that. The book, however, is full of anecdotes about parents who do indeed go to similarly extreme measures in an attempt to secure the best future for their little darlings. They pay for extra tutors, enrol in every after school activity and only allow 'educational' toys at Christmas.
It would be easy to write a review of this book saying that it isn't all that much more than a collection of such anecdotes, admittedly well researched and thoroughly backed up with bona fide science.
The basic premise of the book is that the world has been drawn into over-parenting, that we should sit back and let children be children and just generally relax a little about the whole parenting thing. Perhaps because of this, Honore does not set out to become just another in a long line of preachers telling us how to bring up our children.
Why people would buy this book interests me. A previous reviewer said it must be preaching to the converted which is probably true, but this suggests that even people with enough common sense to reject scheduling a child's activities like the diary of a high flying executive, or tutoring them to the point of exhaustion, need some sort of external affirmation that their view is right - or at least shared.
I probably spend a little too much time seeking that sort of approval, comparing myself to others. Maybe that's what leads to the over-parenting - using children as a way for adults to compete and excel?
The beauty of this book is that, without preaching, it got me thinking about what sort of parent I am and why.
To summarise: I probably didn't need to read the book to realise that 'over-parenting' is bad. I did enjoy lots of interesting anecdotes and research and it definitely did get me thinking - which I suspect is mostly what Carl Honore intended.