For anybody that remembers Face to Face releasing the album "Ignorance is Bliss" back in 1999, you probably also remember what it felt like to have a band seemingly abandon you by writing completely new material. I hated IiB when it first came out, but I figured it was penned by one of my favorite bands, and I should give it a shot. I made myself sit down and listen to the whole thing two or three times, and by the end of the third go-around I realized that I loved the music, although it had moved past my preferred genre of mid-1990's power-pop-punk (or whatever you want to call it).
I had a lot of the same feelings about Saves the Day's In Reverie. I think, for a lot of us who grew up with Can't Slow Down and Through Being Cool, In Reverie was simply too far outside of the scope of the band at first blush. I had to wait fully a year before the final track of the album, Tomorrow Too Late, sunk in and I realized that I had been missing out on some great music because it wasn't what I had been expecting.
So, with that in mind, I've kept my mouth shut about this album for around three years while I've been making up my mind.
First off: the album is good. It's not StD's best effort; Conley's eternal melodrama is wearing a bit thin, although his imagery and lyricism remains as brilliant as ever. The musicianship is what stands out most here. Picking up Glassjaw's rhythm section didn't hurt the group at all, and the bass lines work seamlessly with the drumming throughout. Most of the songs are well-crafted, with a few standout disappointments (Woe being the best example of the filler material required when writing album trilogies).
Second: possibly the best part about being a Saves the Day fan is seeing them live. A lot of bands that sound great in the studio sound terrible on stage. Fortunately, StD isn't one of them. For Under the Boards, the songwriting is tailored much more towards being reproduction live without problems. It's always frustrated me to see Conley start off songs like Rocks Tonic Juice Magic at a concert, and know (via experience) that the layered coda of the song will be missing the harmonized second melody. Under the Boards doesn't suffer from this problem, as there is virtually no vocal harmony anywhere on the album. There are a couple of quick thirds here and there, but nothing approaching the Lifetime/Bad Religion influences of the band's first two albums.
Finally, and this is geared more towards the other reviews on here, I don't understand people saying that they loved Through Being Cool but hated Sound the Alarm. StA remains, in my opinion, the best Saves the Day album produced since Through Being Cool, and that is precisely because it's fast and aggressive. As much as Conley has distanced himself from his New Jersey/punk/Lifetime roots, it's still his best music, and it showed through on Sound the Alarm. But Sound the Alarm this album is not, and it doesn't need to apologize for it. The hooks are there, the landscape of Conley's f*****-up brain is vividly present, and (to be blunt) the album rocks. And this album is not In Reverie, either. Much like In Reverie was a hard swing to (effectively) art rock after Stay What You Are's catchy pop, Under the Boards is moves away from Sound the Alarm. Those kind of perpendicular moves are difficult to handle, even after a band like StD has done it a few times.
To tie back into my opening line, after touring with Trever Keith and his gang, Chris Conley said in an interview that Saves the Day "is not Face to Face." What he meant was that he didn't want to write the same album over and over. While I disagree that Face to Face did that (see Ignorance is Bliss as the strongest evidence), Conley's point makes sense. Nobody wants to get stale, but you can't piss off your fan base too much either. Under the Boards is a good example at balancing Saves the Day's past and future. It doesn't sound quite like any of their other albums, but it's not completely alien.
And, in the meantime, the music is only a few clicks away from achieving greatness. Something tells me I'm not going to need to wait three years to make up my mind when Daybreak comes out.