Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
100 of 107 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting, insightful & impartial, 19 May 2004
By A Customer
If you are expecting a populist best seller challenging the basis of Christian faith, this is the wrong book. What you will be getting instead is a very serious and considered account of the current results of historical and linguistic research into one of most important works of mankind. As a Christian or Jew you can of course expect to be challenged, but not by the ravings of an atheist with an agenda to disprove the existence of God, but instead by a new and sober perspective on the process of the creation of the bible. Divine inspiration or not, Lane Fox allows you to keep to your own council. You will however learn that many readily accepted religious truths about authorship or time of composition of certain texts are indeed the invention of later generations. You might be also surprised as to how some facts, taken commonly as gospel today, have no foundation in the bible, let alone history, but are inventions of the medieval period. Take for example the 'Three Magi' from the Adoration: Casper, Melcher and Balthasar, allegedly three kings now buried in Cologne. Nowhere in the Bible are either their number or their names specified, and nobody in the bible mentions their royalty either. Their names appeared for the first time a remarkable 1100 years later. There are no world changing theories put forward in this book, but it is a very insightful account into the culture and history of the early tribes of Israel and the forces and events that shaped the creation of two major religions. This subject matter is fairly complex and often in need of very thorough explanations. This makes the book somewhat strenuous to read, but to do the subject proper justice it is in my opinion a necessity. The author writes however for the layman and for the interested reader the book is not too hard to follow. Lane Fox has in my opinion approached a very controversial subject with admirable consideration and academic skill. A book that speaks academic truths without trying to offend religious faith or push a specific agenda. Sine ira et studio, one could say.
|
|
|
61 of 65 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Raises the lid on the bible's murky compilation, 12 Jan 2004
I like this book because it makes accessible a fascinating field of work which is very little popularised. The religious position is that the bible's plainly human authors were divinely inspired; the historical position from this book is that more worldly motives were frequently at work. This book examines the evidence for that and gives one a view of the size of the issue, in both testaments.Lane Fox is not a biblical expert, but rather has used his expertise in the common currency of the historian, source criticism. Nonetheless he relies mainly on the work of others, and when he expresses preferences between possible variant conclusions, he (at least appears) to inform you of the alternatives. Particularly interesting is the evidence that extensive parts of the bible have been compiled and edited from earlier by various early authors, and then later recompiled and re-edited, etc. We can infer the particular obsessions and agendas of the principal editors. The existence of the Dead Sea Scrolls, giving many variant texts, provides further evidence that old testament texts had a tendency towards revision in the light of political expediency. The new testment is also examined. Unfortunately a clear conclusion is not available on whether the letters attributed to St Paul have a single author. It also examines whether there is more than one John (gospel vs revelations). The book is a hard read. The problem with a genre such as this is that an author can get away with crankiness and only experts would notice. The book does not appear to be an attempt at sensationalism, nor does the author have an obvious axe to grind, but he is nonetheless aiming at the wider historical market. I have given it 4 stars because it appears that he has apparently made accessible an important area of work that others prefer to obscure. That makes it an important book on my bookshelf.
|
|
|
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A historian's review of the facts available, 6 Jan 2009
This is an examination of the various books that make up the Old and New Testaments from a historical perspective. At no point does it descend into polemic, and when the author is making a best-guess from the available evidence he makes this clear, and explains his reasoning. It is a series of considered judgements, with evidence, and a million miles from some of the sensationalist exposés that are often found in books about the Christian religion.
Yet through it's calmness and rational approach it provides a far more compelling argument against belief than is to be found in the recent spate of anti-religious books, such as "The God Delusion". This isn't through argument against religion, but through careful explanation of the text, the history of the text, and comparisons to evidence that we do have for the time in question. The misunderstandings, and accidents of history that led to the success of the texts that make up the Bible become breathtaking when spelt out within this book.
Note that you need a copy of the bible at hand when reading it!
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Robin Lane Fox
by Robin Lane Fox
by Robin Lane Fox
