They really need to take the "Avengers" out of this title and replace it with "Thunderbolts", because that's what we're reading here. Once you get Captain America out of the way (he's a cameo in this volume), it becomes obvious that Millar really did want to write a Thunderbolts-style story about a bunch of neerdowells. The dynamic of this book makes a lot more sense once you put that together.
The primary cast are still as unlikable and uninspired as can be this time around. I don't want to read about any of these people, unless it's to read about how they were all dropped down an elevator shaft. Only Hawkeye, the last "real" Ultimate/Avenger left at this point, resembles a well-rounded human being in any way. The new addition, Cash, appears to have been stolen right out of the pages of "Youngblood", which, frankly, I'd almost rather be reading.
Why then am I giving this three stars? Well, good news: this story is not about the Ultimates/Avengers. Rather, that crew gets upstaged by the guest stars, the Punisher and Ghost Rider. Normally it's a bad thing when the side characters drive the principle cast out of the spotlight to this degree, but honestly, this time around, it's a serious treat.
The presence of the Punisher in this story is almost comforting. Sure, he's a homicidal maniac, and sure, he's about as sympathetic as shrapnel, but there's a pleasing consistency to it all; he's the same man we've seen for decades now, the same as in every incarnation. There's no jarring or horrifying inconsistencies to be found, like with Millar's Captain America (who traded in his shield and instead took refuge behind some kindergartners in the last volume. Yes, really). This brand of ruthless vigilantism, deplorable though it may be, seems somehow "cleaner" than that of the true scum who now inhabit the rest of this book.
Ghost Rider, surprisingly, is the only real hero we have here. While his story is noticeably reminiscent of "The Crow", it's a hoot and a half to read, and once he takes center stage, it becomes his book entirely. The only disappointment is that we can't keep reading about him once this volume is over. Come back Johnny Blaze, this series needs you! BADLY!
"Crime and Punishment" is a good read, but what to make of the series as a whole? What kind of future is there for these new Avengers/Ultimates/Thunderbolts/Youngbloods? Honestly, I'm just hoping that Thor comes back from the dead and ruins each and every one of them. In fact, if that happens, I'll give retroactive five-star scores to every previous issue. But not until then.