I bought and read this book as soon as it was available and as fast as possible, being a fan of Christian Cameron's historical novels. However, I've hesitated before commenting on it for a couple of months, because I was a bit disappointed. This book has many of the usual ingredients, mentioned already by previous commentators (see "Parmenion", in particular), and I see no need to paraphrase others. Because of these, it is still an excellent read. There are, however, a couple of items which almost spoilt it for me:
- the story of a couple of teen-age twins that manage, almost single handed, to rally support, reconquer their parents' kingdom and defeat all their ennemies is hardly credible. In particular, having Satyrus turning out into a seasoned and talented admiral is a bit much, even if it follows a previous defeat... At times, the book sounds like an adventure story for teenagers, rather than the well-researched and well-written books that ameron had accustomed us to.
- another little issue is the author's tendency to kill of a high number of his secondary characters at the end of some of his novels, which reaches new highs in this one. Seeming aware of this, Cameron seems to try to justify it in his author's note by mentioning that lots of people tended to get killed in battles! It looks like he got tired of some of his characters and chose the easy way out to get rid of them.
Overall, a great read, well above average, but a couple of notches below the first two books with Kineas. Might be time to put an end to this series and focus on the new one around the battle of Marathon.