Top critical review
This book was so bad I threw it in the trash...
on 1 January 2007
This book started out being boring, with no description whatsoever of the characters, and just got worse. In fact, it was so dull that I skipped the whole middle part and read the end. The ending, too, was weird and unsatisfactory.
I just thought this book made no sense whatsoever. The characters were dull and not well described, I didn't know where or when the story took place - it was just bad. It was also, in a way, creepy from the very beginning. I literally threw it in the trash. Do not even LOOK at this book in the bookstore or library. It is crap and besides, who needs to read something like this?
The reason why I wanted to read this book was because I loved the Milk Carton series. In these series, Caroline B. Cooney's writing was actually good. But this book is just bad. If you've read the Milk Carton series and decided you want to read more Caroline B. Cooney books, don't choose this one.