The Dead of Night asks the question 'what would happen to the USA if social order collapsed in the wake of a massive terrorist outrage?'. The answer, according to Brendan DuBois, is Balkan-style division & civil strife, with neighbour attacking neibour based on ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation or any other perceived 'difference' you care to choose. Much of the violence would be coordinated by local 'Militias'; groups of civilian volunteers engaging in wanton killing under the banner of protecting the local population.
This collapse in civilised behaviour would then be followed by an uneasy truce policed and monitored by UN forces. War crime investigators would be despatched to locate evidence of atrocities committed by all sides whilst in the back ground politicians would try to negotiate some sort of lasting peace agreement.
In other words according to DuBois America, despite is military might and technological superiority, is socially only one short step away from descending into the sort of lawless anarchy seen in Bosnia in the 1990's. Whether or not you subscribe to that same belief its a fascinating idea with plenty of dramatic mileage.
Its just a pity therefore, that DuBois creates such a slight and insipid story through which to explore his ideas. Whilst the descriptions of rural north-eastern America in the wake of the recent violence are well done and evoke a suitably eerie and dangerous atmosphere, the central plot is weak. Centred around a disparate group of war crimes investigators searching for the scene of a rumoured mass slaughter of innocent men, women & children, it never really grabs the reader's full attention. The main character, a naive Canadian and former journalist through whose eyes the reader is introduced to this possible future, is too passive to be truly engaging. The rest of the characters are for the most part cliches there to serve a purpose in the plot.
The plot itself unfolds with a sense of weary inevitability. Even the 'twists' can be seen from some distance away. Considering how intriguing the central concept of The Dead of Night Is readers could expect DuBois to make more of it, exploring the wider implications of how America's sudden collapse has impacted the rest of the world. Instead he chooses to focus on one small, predictable story and restricts wider comment to a few asides about trouble on the border with Canada immediately post-atrocity and a few other small background details.
It leaves the reader wanting to know more but having to be satisfied with the limited plot on offer. To add insult to injury DuBois then closes the book with an open ended and comparatively down beat ending that is as unsatisfactory as everything that has come before it.
The book gets two stars for the concept, a fresh take on the 'post-apocalyptic' genre. It gets only one star for what it does with that concept.