Western students of astrology have heard for centuries that the 12th House of the horoscope is a gloomy, dark, isolated place. Karen Hamaker-Sondag, a Dutch Astrologer and Jungian Psychologist, turns that thesis on its head in this interesting book. As a person whose natal chart abounds in 12th House placements and aspects, I was curious to read what insights Hamaker-Sondag could provide.
There are many. Hamaker-Sondag has a brilliant, protean intellect. She is fascinated with all aspects of the human condition. She examines these elements from a variety of cultural perspectives.
THE TWELFTH HOUSE begins with a I Ching hexagram on its first page. Hamaker-Sondag thereafter calls upon an impressive and diverse array of sources to craft her discussion of the 12th House.
The major flaw in this book is that Hamaker-Sondag often digresses from the narrower topics of astrology and the 12th House into larger speculations on Family Dynamics, the Collective Subconscious, Mysticism, Mythology, the dichotomies between Judeo-Christian value systems and Oriental or Neo-Pagan value systems, reincarnation, karma, and so on.
Deconstructed section by section, each of these topics is fascinating, and she writes well and knowledgeably, with an erudition, a depth and a density that is truly gifted, especially for such a brief volume.
Unfortunately, the very density of the material occults Hamaker-Sondag's gifts. Even with my Doctoral degrees in law and psychology, the weight of the material made reading this book more a chore than a pleasure. This seems to be her writing style rather than the translator's impact, as the translator even comments editorially on some of Hamaker-Sondag's material.
This is a book that is less than the sum of its parts, primarily because Hamaker-Sondag fails to segue successfully from one topic to the next or to relate back the various theses that make up her presentation on the 12th House.
It's incredible stuff, but in the end, I had learned more about Hamaker-Sondag's vast range of interests than I did about the 12th House. It made me want to have her do my natal chart or date her, but that wasn't her purpose in writing this book, after all.