As this review will appear on all Amazon versions of the book eventually, I have some comments on the audio version below. But first the story itself:
Tuck is the third book in Lawhead's "King Raven" series that reimagines Robin Hood in a Welsh historical context. If you found this page first, the series starts with "Hood".
The idea is well researched and well imagined. Lawhead clearly has tremendous feeling for all things Celtic, and writes wonderful historical fiction. He is a master at building stories around injustice and conflict and his battle scenes are fast paced and some of the best action writing out there. Unless you hate historical fiction, you will find plenty to enjoy in this book.
There is a well argued afterword about the historical setting which makes an excellent case for a Welsh Robin Hood, although the impartial observer might suggest that Lawhead's decision to base this novel in Wales was down to his love for celtic culture, as evidenced by most of his other works. Nevertheless, this is an excellent work of fiction which I give 5 stars based on its all round interest. I hope you agree with me.
However, I heard this work first on audiobook. I noticed iTunes selling the audio book for less than the price of the paper one, so decided I would listen to it in the car on long drives. I downloaded the whole trilogy, started playing them, and very nearly crashed!
The narrator, Adam Verner, does the worst narration I have ever experienced. Here is a book set in Wales, with Welsh and English place names, and a pronounciation guide at the back, and the narrator manages to pronounce every single place name and every Welsh word incorrectly. The prounciation guide was totally ignored in books one and two. In this book it is applied occasionaly and inconsistently. The overall reading is terribly sloppy, and had me cringing and at times my blood boiling.
Verner is an American. He attempts a British accent, but does a very poor job of it. Sometimes his accent shows through, and he pronounces all words in the american way. A new addition to the narration of this book over the previous two was his attempt to give an accent to some of his character voices. Unfortunately the only accent he can muster is something akin to Rip Van Winkle's travesty of a cockney accent in Mary Poppins.
Thus we have Welsh characters sounding like Americans pretending to be cockney. The effect was exceedingly distracting. On the plus side he seems to have abandoned his scooby doo character voices in this narration.
All in all though, the narration here would get no stars if I could! But the book gets 5 stars. Just buy it on paper or ebook. If you have any desire to hear the words in this book (English place names too) as they should be pronounced, then do not buy the audio book.
I for one will never by another oasis audiobook again.
I will, however, keep reading and enjoying Stephen Lawhead's books.