Frequently Bought Together
What Other Items Do Customers Buy After Viewing This Item?
Product details
|
Reviews
Amazon.co.uk Review
There are many reasons to recommend Troy as a good ol' fashioned Hollywood epic, especially if you've never read Homer's The Iliad. Dispensing with Greek gods altogether, this earnestly massive production (budgeted at upwards of $200 million) will surely offend historians and devoted students of the classics. But there's politics aplenty in the grand-scale war that erupts when Trojan prince Paris (Orlando Bloom) makes off with Helen (blandly beautiful German model Diane Kruger), wife of Spartan ruler Menelaus (Brendan Gleeson), whose brother, the Greek king Agamemnon (Brian Cox) prods him into enraged retaliation. Greek warrior Achilles (Brad Pitt) brings lethal force to his battles (and there are many of them, mostly impressive), and his Trojan counterpart, Paris's brother Hector (Eric Bana), adds even more buffed-up beefcake to a film so chock-full o' hunks that there's barely room for Peter O'Toole (doing fine work as Trojan king Priam) and even less for Julie Christie, appearing ever-so-briefly as Achilles's melancholy mother. The drama is nearly as arid as the sun-baked locations (Mexico and Malta) that stand in for the Aegean coast, and many critics suggested that Pitt (who valiantly tries to give Achilles some tormented dimension) was simply miscast. But when you consider that Wolfgang Petersen also made The Perfect Storm, there's nothing wrong with enjoying Troy as a semi-guilty pleasure with a touch of ancient class. --Jeff Shannon
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
Customer Reviews
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
64 of 67 people found the following review helpful
Format:DVD
Troy (Director's Cut) is so much better than the theatrical version that it is almost hard to believe that they are in essence the same movie. That is not to say that this new version is perfect, it isn't. As with the Theatrical version, the acting is in some instances passable at best and it takes quite a few liberties with the accepted version of events according to Homer. However, what it does do is make the film run far more smoothly than it did before. Considering over 30 minutes of footage has been restored it actually seems to make the film a lot tighter than it was before. The rather disjointed, lacking in focus theatrical version is now replaced with a movie that always keeps you engrossed. Not just in the battle scenes which are really quite brilliant but also in the political intrigues and infighting amongst both the Greeks and the Trojans. Brad Pitt always seems to divide people as to his worth as an actor. I happen to think he is actually quite good. In Troy he is the leading man and he does a good job of holding the film together. According to Homer, Achilles was the most beautiful and the deadliest warrior of his age. Pitt is undoubtedly in excellent physical condition but he also manages to convey Achilles coldness and mastery of arms. His Achilles is a killing machine who cares for almost nothing but his own personal glory. He knows what his alternative futures are before he sails to Troy, but he would rather die young covered in glory than live to be old surrounded by love. There is a vacant look in Achilles eyes almost as though he is aware of everything that is happening around him but doesn't really care as long as it does not seem to personally affect him. However, in war, every action has a knock on effect and Achilles discovers this to his own personal loss. Achilles is not an easy role to take on, but Pitt does it well and he makes Troy a better film because of it.
On a side note, why do film companies continue to keep on ripping off the average punter who buys DVD's. If you are a film fan you are always going to want to see exactly what the director wanted to show in the first place. I can accept that for the theatre sometimes you have to trim the film down a little to make it a more palatable running time for people to be prepared to go and see or in some cases to cut down on some of the director's wilder excesses. But surely when they release the DVD they could make both the theatrical and the director's version available at the same time or on the same package. After all it's not like the footage isn't already available. Too many times I have come across extended additions and director's cuts, mere months after they have released the theatrical version. I know it's too much to hope for that they will stop ripping us off, but I would just like them to know that it's pretty poor show from them.
On a side note, why do film companies continue to keep on ripping off the average punter who buys DVD's. If you are a film fan you are always going to want to see exactly what the director wanted to show in the first place. I can accept that for the theatre sometimes you have to trim the film down a little to make it a more palatable running time for people to be prepared to go and see or in some cases to cut down on some of the director's wilder excesses. But surely when they release the DVD they could make both the theatrical and the director's version available at the same time or on the same package. After all it's not like the footage isn't already available. Too many times I have come across extended additions and director's cuts, mere months after they have released the theatrical version. I know it's too much to hope for that they will stop ripping us off, but I would just like them to know that it's pretty poor show from them.
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful
Format:DVD
One of the best of the recent spate of epics, Troy isn't a faithful version of Homer's Illiad by any means - the Gods are ommitted, Petrochlus becomes Achilles', er, 'cousin,' while Achilles lives long enough to climb the walls of Troy in its death-throes while other characters meet premature ends - but for me at least the changes in David Benioff's really quite impressive screenplay are far from objectionable and often make emotional sense. Unlike Oliver Stone's Alexander, Benioff's screenplay is able to marry big, mythical themes, most notably the need for immortality through killing that drives many of the characters to their deaths, with strong storytelling and good characterization. Sadly, the cast aren't always quite up to the words, but they're still lightyears ahead of the miscasting contest in Robert Wise's 1955 Helen of Troy (which compensated with real rather than digital extras and a much cooler wooden horse).
Rather than focussing on Helen (not a bad thing with Diane Kruger unmemorable in the role), it centers on Achilles' lust for glory and his conflict with Hector and his own leader Agamemnon. In many ways its more about conflicting codes of honour than the traditional big romantic adventure treatment the story usually gets, but the wildly inconsistent Wolfgang Petersen does one of his better jobs here, balancing impressive spectacle and action sequences with a convincing human drama to deliver an intelligent and exciting epic. He even manages to elicit good performances from usually erratic supporting players like Sean Bean and the oft-wooden Saffron Burrows. Some of the digital effects look a lot less impressive on the small screen than they did on the big one, but not enough of them to detract.
Rather than focussing on Helen (not a bad thing with Diane Kruger unmemorable in the role), it centers on Achilles' lust for glory and his conflict with Hector and his own leader Agamemnon. In many ways its more about conflicting codes of honour than the traditional big romantic adventure treatment the story usually gets, but the wildly inconsistent Wolfgang Petersen does one of his better jobs here, balancing impressive spectacle and action sequences with a convincing human drama to deliver an intelligent and exciting epic. He even manages to elicit good performances from usually erratic supporting players like Sean Bean and the oft-wooden Saffron Burrows. Some of the digital effects look a lot less impressive on the small screen than they did on the big one, but not enough of them to detract.
33 of 35 people found the following review helpful
Format:DVD
What a let down the original movie was,slow, ponderous,shallow and completely forgettable.
I'm very much a fan of historical epics and my expectations of troy were high,particularly with the cast and crew they had on board.It was however a complete let down and seemed a view shared by many people i spoke to who had watched the movie.The score was dreadful,the characters were lacking in exposition and cause,the mtv style editing,particularly of the battle scenes was a mess ,i could go on and on but now i don't need to.
This new version is terrific,its like watching a new movie,the additional 30 minutes have added so much more to the film,character development is improved,the film feels epic,the new musical score fits in like a dream and the extended fight scenes of which there are many,all do justice to wolfgang petersen's desire to produce this new cut.
I can't praise it enough and if you had doubts over the original movie,then buy this,it really is worth having.
A 5 star recommendation.
I'm very much a fan of historical epics and my expectations of troy were high,particularly with the cast and crew they had on board.It was however a complete let down and seemed a view shared by many people i spoke to who had watched the movie.The score was dreadful,the characters were lacking in exposition and cause,the mtv style editing,particularly of the battle scenes was a mess ,i could go on and on but now i don't need to.
This new version is terrific,its like watching a new movie,the additional 30 minutes have added so much more to the film,character development is improved,the film feels epic,the new musical score fits in like a dream and the extended fight scenes of which there are many,all do justice to wolfgang petersen's desire to produce this new cut.
I can't praise it enough and if you had doubts over the original movie,then buy this,it really is worth having.
A 5 star recommendation.
Would you like to see more reviews about this item?
Were these reviews helpful?
Let us know
Most Recent Customer Reviews
Troy !
For anyone who watched the original, enjoyed it, but wondered what if - yes, finally, here is the directors cut of one of the finest high adventure movies ever made (stands... Read more
Published 13 days ago by Gs Venter
Buy This... For The Screenplay Alone!!
Personally, I have been a fan of Troy since its original release to cinemas back in 2004. I now own the 2-disc edition of the original film, not this new Director's Cut I've heard... Read more
Published 1 month ago by Fox in the Box
The majestic movie it should always have been
You don't have to be a fan of Homer to enjoy this movie (if you're a die-hard fan you might find it wanders a little too far in some respects from the original poems), but if... Read more
Published 1 month ago by Mr D T Watson
Epic, but far from Homer....
CGI gets its hands on The Iliad, in Wolfgang Peterson's long sword and sandal epic and propels into - and for - 21st century audiences. Read more
Published 1 month ago by Tim Kidner
This is a character assassination of the Achilles of 'The Iliad'...
Terrible. Wooden acting all round. Good photography and special effects wasted on a rubbishy film that makes for a travesty of 'The Iliad'. Read more
Published 5 months ago by workoutsforbreakfast
Great production
Bought this to supplement my DVD version, as Amamzon had it at a fantastic price! It's way better, with lots of additional scenes not on the DVD. Read more
Published 6 months ago by ragspeed
Better than expected
I remembered watching this film years ago, but couldn't really remember it, so decided to watch it again last weekend. Read more
Published 7 months ago by Abby
Orlando Bloom oh my god why?
A terrible film just worsened by the fact the stamp of awfulness that is Orlando Bloom stars in it. This is the equivalent of having a terrible uncurable disease and then a doctor... Read more
Published 7 months ago by Steve ALbini
troy
am very happy with this dvd it came with in a few days of ordering cant wait to watch troy
Published 8 months ago by debbie
Great literature with all the literature taken out
The best I can say that while not absolutely dreadful, this film is pretty bad. The script is poor and sounds as if it was written in German and translated into English using flaky... Read more
Published 9 months ago by CraggyDVD
Customer Discussions
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|
![[Start the discussion]](http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/02/x-locale/communities/discussion_boards/start-new-discussion-sec._V192198663_.gif){kind=small}
Listmania!
|
|
Look for similar items by category
Look for similar items by subject
Feedback
- Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
