Just when you thought travel writers had exhausted their subject matter - like, dare we say it, the dwindling north Atlantic cod supply - O'Hanlon breaks waves with an unusual, and quite remarkable voyage of self-discovery on an Aberdeen fishing trawler. It's ironic to think that the "mad and seasick" writer left his "safe, warm house in peaceful Oxfordshire" to endure this cold, cruel sea hardship so listeners can enjoy a little escapist adventure in the comfort of their favourite fireside armchair. But Michael Palin he is not. Reading the book himself, O'Hanlon's flat, breathless tones become monotonous and his amateur dramatic attempts at characterisation with a dreadful Scottish accent is simply dire.
Nevertheless, it's a fine fisherman's tale that will make you appreciate your next haddock supper.
Kelvin MacGregor, The Herald, Glasgow